Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hatrack

(64,771 posts)
11. This is a press release, not proof of concept or a peer-reviewed scientific paper . . .
Mon Mar 16, 2026, 10:35 PM
Monday

"Fusion, the power source of the sun, is coming to Earth as a disruptive new energy technology." Mkay . . .

"We fervently believe . . . " Yes and I can fervently believe that Quaker State 10W40 is the blood of Christ, that Hitler is living in Brazil, or that Taco Bell sells "food". The fervor of my beliefs has nothing to do with their validity.

"We expect our first ARC fusion power plant will start putting watts on the grid in Chesterfield County, Virginia, in the early 2030s." If it pans out, I'll be happy to applaud accordingly. However, for now it's a self-driving Tesla (flying or otherwise), the Metaverse or New Coke, until proven otherwise.

"A global race for fusion is shaping up: there are now 53 fusion energy companies around the world that have raised over $10 billion in capital." So, $10 billion divided by 53 = +/- $189 million per company. Vogtle 3 and 4 together cost more than $30 billion for two light water fission reactors. Will these 53 companies pool their resources to strain towards a total of (roughly) two orders of magnitude X 0.5 less in funding than that needed to complete two fission units?

Look, I'd be happy to see this succeed, but there's a lot of techno-hopium currently under deployment across multiple technologies and scientific disciplines (geoengineering, AI, autonomous vehicles), and my first reaction to bold announcements like this is skepticism. Sorry if that makes me a "naysayer", but skepticism is more necessary than ever these days, IMO.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Coming soon - "How US States Can Attract Herds Of Unicorns" hatrack Monday #1
This is not some start-up run by dreamers OKIsItJustMe Monday #3
Right. I would have said to the naysayer "Can't we have a little optimism?" FadedMullet Monday #4
Well, as optimistic as I am that we will have commercial fusion soon... OKIsItJustMe Monday #6
Given our new reality of server "farms" popping up everywhere, you're probably right. FadedMullet Monday #7
So, imagine we can snap our fingers and tomorrow have a fusion-powered grid OKIsItJustMe Monday #8
Jeez, where does the other half come from? I know it's not cow farts. FadedMullet 9 hrs ago #18
Well, actually, some does come from methane from cows, although they generally belch it out OKIsItJustMe 8 hrs ago #20
This is a press release, not proof of concept or a peer-reviewed scientific paper . . . hatrack Monday #11
One of these fusion startups is in WA thought crime 24 min ago #21
It's the 75th anniversary of the Princeton Plasma Physics Lab. NNadir Monday #12
And Edison made a coal burning plant in 1844 OKIsItJustMe 15 hrs ago #15
Really? Edison ran a coal plant in 1844, three years before his birth? NNadir 14 hrs ago #16
A Star in a Bottle: The Quest for Commercial Fusion OKIsItJustMe Monday #5
Energy as limitless abundance will outpace all other inputs bucolic_frolic Monday #2
Hmmm lonely bird Monday #9
The direct product of the fusion reaction is heat OKIsItJustMe Monday #10
Sure lonely bird 16 hrs ago #13
The great breakthrough of this design OKIsItJustMe 15 hrs ago #14
How are they generating the hot plasma? lonely bird 10 hrs ago #17
Multiple methods are used to initially heat the plasma OKIsItJustMe 8 hrs ago #19
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»How U.S. states can attra...»Reply #11