Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cirsium

(4,252 posts)
36. Absurd
Tue Jun 30, 2026, 02:35 PM
9 hrs ago

85% of the population, over 220 million people, were born in the country. They are US citizens by virtue of being born in the US. All have ancestors who were not born in the US.

None of this has anything to do with birth right citizenship. No one is talking about stripping 220 million people of their citizenship. It is about white nationalism, and we shouldn't pretend that it is about anything else.

Right here the other day I saw someone post "I agree that people shouldn't hop across the border to have a baby." Sure. Those women in Norway go into labor and then hop on a plane to the US. Oh, wait. It isn't Norwegians they are worried about, is it? This insanity isn't about foreigners, either. It is Black and brown people who are being targeted in various ways, no matter their status, no matter where they were born or where their parents were born.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

"Children born in the United States to parents unlawfully or temporarily present are 'subject to the jurisdiction' of t riversedge 10 hrs ago #1
He's the annoying boy arguing again Torchlight 10 hrs ago #2
The supreme court was 5-4 against that specific claim Renew Deal 10 hrs ago #3
Ok, I am confused. mwmisses4289 10 hrs ago #8
5-4 for the most important part obamanut2012 10 hrs ago #10
So 5-4 for some of it, 6-3 for other parts? mwmisses4289 10 hrs ago #12
Yes, Brett the Rapey was part of the 5-4 Constitutional issue, and 6-3 on the other obamanut2012 9 hrs ago #21
6-3 Renew Deal 10 hrs ago #11
This would not even make it to the floor in the Senate. It's dead. Takket 10 hrs ago #4
And even if it did, it would be struck down again by the Supreme Court. Wiz Imp 10 hrs ago #13
I think birthright citizenship is safe for the time being but the makeup of 5-4 SCOTUS ruling is rarely irrelevant Ilikepurple 7 hrs ago #45
Trump is a dumbass... appmanga 10 hrs ago #5
Well he and congress can start movement on a Constitutional Amendment 31j20b3 10 hrs ago #6
Yo rapist Whip-poor-will 10 hrs ago #7
Anybody pointed out to dumbfuck that mwmisses4289 10 hrs ago #9
as if it gives a fuck dave99 10 hrs ago #16
Isn't the EO only for newborns? FakeNoose 9 hrs ago #19
Ah, you are probably right. mwmisses4289 9 hrs ago #23
That one brain cell or amoeba or whatever it is in there that makes his jowls flap does want that lol n/t Cheezoholic 9 hrs ago #33
It could be the green algae talking too. GreenWave 8 hrs ago #43
Nah your initial thought was right standingtall 9 hrs ago #34
ALL shitstains school records under lock&NDAs, tells you it is stupid dave99 10 hrs ago #14
"Quiet, rapist piggy" W_HAMILTON 10 hrs ago #15
Stupid!!!! paleotn 10 hrs ago #17
Congress can override the constitution. Kablooie 10 hrs ago #18
Congress can override the constitution dweller 9 hrs ago #38
My neaderthal congressman is ready to vote to end birthright citizenship Danmel 9 hrs ago #20
Quiet, slob SheltieLover 9 hrs ago #22
Stephen Miller must be blowing smoke up his ass again. Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin 9 hrs ago #24
Why can't this pox on humanity just slither away? Grim Chieftain 9 hrs ago #25
Should someone tell him? eezapata 9 hrs ago #26
Look boy..... SergeStorms 9 hrs ago #32
You can't spell "Congress," Donny. SergeStorms 9 hrs ago #27
Pedo knows nothing about everything. City Lights 9 hrs ago #28
He's preaching to what's left of his choir. progressoid 9 hrs ago #29
If he's so good with tests and ace them all, let's see if he can pass a citizenship test new citizens have to pass Deuxcents 9 hrs ago #30
He pays ppl to take his tests for him dweller 7 hrs ago #46
Isn't that special ;) n/t Cheezoholic 9 hrs ago #31
I doubt he could even spell "unwieldy" lol La Coliniere 9 hrs ago #35
I'm sure you're right. ShazzieB 8 hrs ago #40
Absurd Cirsium 9 hrs ago #36
If that's the case Nasruddin 9 hrs ago #37
Oops, somebody just told Baby Donnie how constitutional amendments work! ShazzieB 8 hrs ago #39
SCOTUS to TRUMP: "And we'll just vote that unconstitutional act down!" ColoringFool 8 hrs ago #41
The Heritage Foundation needs to be fucking destroyed. Initech 8 hrs ago #42
TRUMP HAS NEVER EVEN READ THE CONSTITUTION Jimvanhise 8 hrs ago #44
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump just tweeted--and i...»Reply #36