Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Environment & Energy

Showing Original Post only (View all)

NNadir

(38,590 posts)
Sat May 23, 2026, 03:12 AM Saturday

We're Saved! Chinese Green Coal Guys Use High Entropy Alloys to Make Hydrogen Electrodes!!!! [View all]

The paper to which I'll refer in this post is this one: High-Entropy FeCoCuNiMo Selenide Electrocatalysts with Tunable Selenization for Efficient Hydrogen Evolution in Alkaline Media Mengmeng Zhou, Ziwu Liu, Kaijia Wang, Huanqiang Shi, Ziting Wang, Hao Yan, Zelin Tong, Fang Wang, Shijian Lu, Zhonghai Ni, and Guiqing Liu Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 2026 65 (17), 8827-8836

I'm not going to talk too much about this paper other than to express some amusement, because one hears a lot of things one doesn't want to believe that one is hearing.

Around here in the DU forum we get lots of slick videos from the fossil fuel industry about electrolytic hydrogen in China, the country with the most coal plants in the world, over 1,000 of them with over 90 now under various stages of construction. Usually in the bait and switch bit used internationally by the fossil fuel industry these electrolytic hydrogen schemes are advertised as "green," by showing vast stretches of industrial parks covered with solar cells, all of which will be rotting electronic waste within a generation.

The paper referenced above says it's about "green" hydrogen from so called "renewable energy."

Wow! We're saved.

First off, a brief comment about high entropy alloys. These are real. When my son and I were touring materials science departments of perspective universities when he was in high school, at one of the tables - at the university where he ultimately received his undergraduate and master's degrees - they had a demonstration of a high entropy alloy which one of the professors discussed with my son. These are alloys designed to not have defined crystal structures, i.e. with randomized structures, giving them special properties. (I am in no way an expert on these properties and cannot riff very much on them.)

Anyway, about the "green" hydrogen in China, from the introduction:

The growing global energy demand and environmental concerns highlight the need for efficient and sustainable clean energy technologies. (1−4) Among various clean energy carriers, hydrogen has emerged as a promising alternative to fossil fuels owing to its high gravimetric energy density and zero carbon emissions. (5−7) Water electrolysis is a key method for producing “green” hydrogen using renewable electricity, but its efficiency is significantly constrained by the intrinsically sluggish kinetics of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) at the cathode. Efficient electrocatalysts are essential to lower the energy barrier (overpotential) of this reaction. (8−11) Although noble metal-based catalysts, particularly Pt, remain the benchmark for HER performance, their high cost and limited natural abundance severely restrict large-scale industrial applications. (12−18) This has spurred intensive research into earth-abundant alternatives. (19) In this context, 3d transition metal-based materials represented by iron (Fe), cobalt (Co), and nickel (Ni) have attracted extensive attention as promising alternatives to noble metal catalysts due to their natural abundance, low cost, and considerable catalytic potential. Accordingly, a variety of catalytic systems have been developed, including transition metal oxides, hydroxides, sulfides, phosphides, nitrides, and alloys, achieving substantial progress in water electrolysis. (20−22) Among them, transition metal selenides (TMSes) have gained considerable attention due to their tunable electronic structures, favorable hydrogen adsorption free energy, and good electrical conductivity, rendering them promising candidates for HER in alkaline media. (23−25)

Nevertheless, traditional TMSes often suffer from limitations such as insufficient density of catalytically active sites and poor long-term stability under high current densities, which restrict their practical applications. (26,27) The synergistic interactions arising from multimetal compositions can optimize the hydrogen adsorption free energy and accelerate the reaction kinetics. (28) High-entropy materials (HEMs), composed of five or more principal elements in near-equimolar ratios, exhibit unique properties such as high-entropy effects, severe lattice distortion, sluggish diffusion kinetics, and cocktail effects. These characteristics contribute to superior electrocatalytic performance compared to lower-entropy counterparts. (29,30) The compositional tunability of HEMs allows for the design of catalysts with optimized electronic structures, leading to enhanced intrinsic activity and improved stability. (31) For instance, Jiang et al. (32) demonstrated the superior performance of a flower-like high-entropy selenide (CoNiFeCuCr)Se synthesized via a two-step solvothermal method, outperforming its quaternary, ternary, binary, and unary analogues. Furthermore, in situ growth of catalytic materials on conductive substrates like metallic foams presents significant advantages: it circumvents the need for polymeric binders, which can impede conductivity and block active sites, provides excellent electrical contact, facilitates mass transport through inherent porosity, and ensures robust mechanical adhesion. (33,34) Crucially, the physicochemical properties and electrocatalytic performance of selenide catalysts are strongly dependent on selenization parameters, particularly the temperature and duration. These factors govern the kinetics of metal–selenium bond formation, thus affecting the crystallinity, phase composition, and nature of the active phases. Therefore, controlling selenization conditions is vital for tailoring the electrocatalytic properties of high-entropy selenides...


It races across the late transition metals of the third period to make this alloy, iron-cobalt-nickel-copper then throws in a little molybdenum and selenium. Um...delicious! Cobalt is, of course, a famous "conflict metal" relying on modern African slavery or near slavery as a source, and the subject of much effort by American, European and Chinese neocolonial efforts to control.

But let's not get all teary eyed about it: HYDROGEN!!!!!! We're saved!!!!!

Look, scientifically the paper is of some interest. Despite all the bullshit thrown around here, electrolytic hydrogen is not really a "thing." It's showcase stuff, a bait and switch game, as the paper points out, dependent on rare and expensive platinum, poor kinetics, and high expense. Almost all of the world's hydrogen is made by steam reformation of fossil fuels. In China, the fossil fuel mostly used is coal; elsewhere it is mostly the fuel fossil gas methane, the second most important greenhouse gas, say, in antinuke heaven, Germany, where methane purchased by the Germans from Putin funded Putin's war on Ukraine.

HYDROGEN!!!!!! We're saved!!!!!

GREEEEEEEENNNNN, GREEEEEENNNN, HYROGEN! We're saved!!!!

Look, the alloy is cool, and I believe the authors, all eleven of them, that this may represent an advantage over expensive and rare and sluggish platinum. There really isn't enough platinum on Earth to make electrolytic hydrogen a "thing" even if we overlook that electricity is a severely thermodynamically degraded source of energy, despite all the bullshit we hear here and elsewhere.

About those 11 authors: They're all from the same institution.

What is the institution you may ask. Let me tell you by sharing with you who the corresponding author is:

Ziwu Liu - Jiangsu Key Laboratory of Coal-based Greenhouse Gas Control and Utilization, School of Chemical Engineering and Jiangsu Province Engineering Laboratory of High Efficient Energy Storage Technology and Equipment, China University of Mining & Technology, Xuzhou ,221008Jiangsu, China;


I added the italics, bold and underlining.

We live in Orwellian times. There are few phrases quite as Orwellian as "Coal Based Greenhouse Gas Control." It's pure doublespeak.

I'm hardly suicidal; like many people I want to live as long as I can, but in some sense, with doublespeak like this flying around seriously there's something not all that bad about leaving life behind.

I'd laugh, but it's not really funny.

Have a pleasant Memorial day weekend. It's supposed to rain through most of it here in New Jersey. We need it.
3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»We're Saved! Chinese Gre...»Reply #0