Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(38,391 posts)
20. Thank you for the guilt by association fallacy. Let's go full Godwin.
Wed Apr 29, 2026, 03:58 PM
Wednesday

Adolf Hitler asked Ferdinand Porche to design a People's Car, in German a "Volkswagen."

The result was the Volkswagen Bug. There's a picture of Hitler admiring the car on the internet.

When I was a young hippie type, I and many of my friends drove bugs. They were cheap and had impressive gas mileage for that time. Is the logic of the antinukism now that all hippies who drove Volkswagen Bugs were Nazis?

If the Orange Peophile in the White House says that a golf ball is a sphere - assuming he knows what a sphere is - does that mean that it is an tetrahedron?

There's also a picture on the ORNL website of smiling Jacquiline and John Kennedy with Al Gore's father, in the control room of a nuclear reactor at the Oak Ridge in 1959 with Alvin Weinberg . I would be an appalling idiot if I claimed this as a reason to support Molten Salt reactors. The reactors stand or fail on their technical performance, not on what politicians thought or think of them.

George W. Bush has solar cells on his ranch, but I'm not such a moron as to use this to assert that solar cells are unsustainable garbage. They're unsustainable garbage in my view whether Bush uses them or not.

That former Secretaries of Energy Steven Chu and Jennifer Granholm both supported nuclear energy has no bearing on whether nuclear energy has a low carbon impact. The carbon impact may be why they supported it but the number itself has no relationship to their opinion of it.

We seem to be having a festival of desperate whining today, pulling out logical fallacy after logical fallacy to support the unsupportable.

Again, in case we missed it the first time, trillions of dollars have been squandered on solar and wind, vast mines constructed to make them, and vast stretches of former wilderness industrialized to install them. They have had no effect on the rise in concentration of the dangerous fossil fuel waste carbon dioxide. I monitor this pretty much every damned day.

The "hydrogen will save us" moron engages in this type of rhetoric "guilt by association" all the time,. It does not change the fact that China is adding over 90 new coal plants to the more than 1000 they have now.

In the last two weeks, the rate of increase at the Mauna Loa CO2 Observatory has slowed.

I suspect the slowing of the rate of carbon dioxide increases in the last two weeks to be attributable tobthe closure of the Straits of Hormuz and higher oil and gas prices. If I'm right about that does this make the Orange Pedophile in the White House an environmentalist? Does this make his war a good thing?

This unserious nonsense is tellling.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Oh good. After tearing the mountains to pieces for coal... NNadir Wednesday #1
They want to... 2naSalit Wednesday #4
Leaving big holes like this one OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #7
In the fast neutron spectrum with the dumped thorium from lanthanide mining for... NNadir Wednesday #10
Your insistence that "renewable energy" is not green is contradicted by the experts. OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #12
I don't credit "Appeal to authority" arguments. NNadir Wednesday #14
There's nothing particularly wrong with an appeal to authority. You use it all the time. OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #16
Well ain't that nice blue-wave Wednesday #2
Except...the next generation of EV batteries are supposed to use little to no lithium Fiendish Thingy Wednesday #3
There's always something wonderful on the horizon. NNadir Wednesday #5
The bulk of BC's household energy comes from hydro Fiendish Thingy Wednesday #8
I have been writing here for over 20 years on energy. NNadir Wednesday #11
Thank you for your opinions IMHO they resemble those of our President OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #19
Thank you for the guilt by association fallacy. Let's go full Godwin. NNadir Wednesday #20
No guilt by association intended OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #21
Oh, I sure hope I'm the "hydrogen will save us" moron you refer to. thought crime Wednesday #23
No, I wasn't thinking of you. If however you wish to... NNadir Thursday #24
Do you know how to use search engines? OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #9
Well if one doesn't give a shit about the laws of thermodyamics, one could... NNadir Wednesday #13
Your response to evidence is belligerent denial of the truth OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #15
Thank you for sharing your opinion. NNadir Wednesday #17
I'm sorry, I should have said "virtually" every expert OKIsItJustMe Wednesday #18
There's always some technology on the horizon that will supposedly save our asses from the fire. hunter Wednesday #6
Yes, we just have to do it. thought crime Wednesday #22
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Appalachian lithium cache...»Reply #20