The DU Lounge

Aristus

(71,478 posts)

19. In Ellison's defense, he knew it was a cliched idea when he pitched it.

Thu Jan 16, 2025, 11:55 AM

Jan 2025

He was at a series pitch meeting his agent set up for him, and he was coming up with ideas for a science-fiction television show. And the dumb fuck studio executive taking the meeting shot down idea after idea after idea.

Finally, out of patience, Ellison hit him with the most overdone, hackneyed plot he could think of: a space ark/generational ship story, which, as you pointed out, has been around forever.

The dumb fuck executive thought it was thrillingly original (of course) and ordered a story treatment. The whole tangled mess is related in one of Ellison’s essays on working in Hollyweird. But the heart of it is, Ellison knew it was a played-out idea from the start.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

41 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

what was the most god awfal tv show , movie or book. [View all] AllaN01Bear Jan 2025 OP

The Happening is the worst movie I've ever seen. yourout Jan 2025 #1

Battlefield Earth Shellback Squid Jan 2025 #2

It was an interesting book... JT45242 Jan 2025 #5

Most of the book was good LogDog75 Jan 2025 #7

Waiting to exhale JT45242 Jan 2025 #3

The Gong Show Chipper Chat Jan 2025 #4

I watched it, too. murielm99 Jan 2025 #13

Napoleon Dynamite Cartoonist Jan 2025 #6

That sucked too JT45242 Jan 2025 #9

It took a second viewing for the humor to click with me. nt Shermann Jan 2025 #26

original The Happening was not a hit either, except the theme song which hit number one.... nt msongs Jan 2025 #8

I thought I was the only person left alive who remembered there was an original! ms liberty Jan 2025 #36

Funny you mentioned Earth Arc; I was thinking of a short-lived series called Earth Two. Through some contrived situation NBachers Jan 2025 #10

Too many unbelievables piled on top of each other. eppur_se_muova Jan 2025 #17

Any show with a title starting with "The Real Housewives of..." flvegan Jan 2025 #11

My wife watches regularly Conjuay Jan 2025 #22

Atlas Shrugged Movies - Parts 1, 2, and 3 Rigpa108 Jan 2025 #12

Well... LudwigPastorius Jan 2025 #14

The Human Centipede LeftInTX Jan 2025 #15

Starlost: created by Harlan Ellison, who separated from the project after too many changes. eppur_se_muova Jan 2025 #16

In Ellison's defense, he knew it was a cliched idea when he pitched it. Aristus Jan 2025 #19

Interesting ! Strange that I didn't recall any of that from the version I read. Not sure where it was, unfortunately ... eppur_se_muova Jan 2025 #20

The entire experience is recounted in Ellison's essay Aristus Jan 2025 #21

Harlan Ellison was pretty much persona non grata PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2025 #37

The anthology in question, The Last Dangerous Visions, Aristus Jan 2025 #40

I did not know that. Thank you. PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2025 #41

"Postern of Fate" by Agatha Christie. C0RI0LANUS Jan 2025 #18

My Mother The Car justaprogressive Jan 2025 #23

And to think... Different Drummer Jan 2025 #25

My sister gives me videos she buys in thrift stores, and one of them is a real doozy. Archae Jan 2025 #24

Definitely a bad movie. Different Drummer Jan 2025 #27

"Nightflyers" Shermann Jan 2025 #28

Television gay texan Jan 2025 #29

Howard the Duck. cloudbase Jan 2025 #30

Captain Caveman ( cartoon, Hanna-Barbera) Trellastic Jan 2025 #31

The Brady Bunch Variety Hour Mike Nelson Jan 2025 #32

Chariots of Fire Emile Jan 2025 #33

A.I. Bmoboy Jan 2025 #34

Movie: "The Blair Witch Project" DBoon Jan 2025 #35

Love Story, both the book and movie. PoindexterOglethorpe Jan 2025 #38

Frankly, I found this one a bit hard to get through. Different Drummer Jan 2025 #39