Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Furious Democrats Reportedly Float Dramatic Idea:Throwing Out Virginia's Supreme Court to Push Through Gerrymandered map [View all]LetMyPeopleVote
(181,720 posts)3. A Private Call Reveals Democrats' Desperation Over Tossing of Map (NYT gift article)
I personally believe that given the ruling by Alito and other GOP gerrymandering, the steps outlined here are appropriate.
Link to tweet
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/10/us/politics/democrats-virginia-plans-gerrymandering.html?unlocked_article_code=1.hVA.KzAI.Wf17nRa9PSjl&smid=nytcore-ios-share
During a private discussion on Saturday that included Democratic House members from Virginia and Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, the minority leader, the lawmakers vented anger at their defeat at the Virginia Supreme Court, spoke about a collective determination to flip two or three Republican-held seats under the existing map and discussed a bank-shot proposal to redraw the congressional lines anyway, according to three people who participated in the call and two others who were briefed on it.....
Any plans to enact a new congressional map for this years midterm elections would require action in the next few days. In a court filing last month, Steven Koski, the commissioner of the Virginia Department of Elections, said any changes to the maps after Tuesday, May 12, will significantly increase the risk of his agency being unable to properly prepare for the states scheduled Aug. 4 primary election......
One key to the plan would be having Democrats in Richmond lower the mandatory retirement age for state Supreme Court justices, an idea that began circulating among state lawmakers and members of Congress after a column proposing a version of the idea was published on Friday night in The Downballot, a progressive newsletter.
Ms. Spanberger would have to sign off on any legislation that lowered the judicial retirement age. She has not been briefed on the proposal, the people involved in the discussion or briefed on it said. Her spokeswoman, Libby Wiet, declined to comment.
The first step in the process, as discussed on the delegations call, would be to invoke a January ruling by a circuit court judge in Tazewell County, Va., that said the 2026 constitutional amendment effort to redraw the maps was invalid because county officials did not post notice of it at courthouses and other public locations three months before a general election.
Representative Suhas Subramanyam, a Democrat who represents Loudoun County, Va., said in an interview that he supported doing whatever was necessary to preserve the map voters approved in last months referendum including replacing the states Supreme Court justices.
Everyone has got to have a strong stomach right now; this is a complete disaster waiting to happen if people are timid, said Mr. Subramanyam, who was on the Saturday call. We have Republican states ignoring their constitutions and interrupting early voting and ignoring their Supreme Courts all together. We know based on that, Republicans would explore every single option possible to move this forward.....
In an interview on Friday night, before his Saturday meeting with Virginia lawmakers, Mr. Jeffries said he was exploring how to unravel this decision.
Its an all-hands-on-deck moment, and its unprecedented in American history as far as we can tell that an actual election has been overturned by a handful of unelected judges, Mr. Jeffries said. Were not going to step back, we will continue to fight back.
Any plans to enact a new congressional map for this years midterm elections would require action in the next few days. In a court filing last month, Steven Koski, the commissioner of the Virginia Department of Elections, said any changes to the maps after Tuesday, May 12, will significantly increase the risk of his agency being unable to properly prepare for the states scheduled Aug. 4 primary election......
One key to the plan would be having Democrats in Richmond lower the mandatory retirement age for state Supreme Court justices, an idea that began circulating among state lawmakers and members of Congress after a column proposing a version of the idea was published on Friday night in The Downballot, a progressive newsletter.
Ms. Spanberger would have to sign off on any legislation that lowered the judicial retirement age. She has not been briefed on the proposal, the people involved in the discussion or briefed on it said. Her spokeswoman, Libby Wiet, declined to comment.
The first step in the process, as discussed on the delegations call, would be to invoke a January ruling by a circuit court judge in Tazewell County, Va., that said the 2026 constitutional amendment effort to redraw the maps was invalid because county officials did not post notice of it at courthouses and other public locations three months before a general election.
Representative Suhas Subramanyam, a Democrat who represents Loudoun County, Va., said in an interview that he supported doing whatever was necessary to preserve the map voters approved in last months referendum including replacing the states Supreme Court justices.
Everyone has got to have a strong stomach right now; this is a complete disaster waiting to happen if people are timid, said Mr. Subramanyam, who was on the Saturday call. We have Republican states ignoring their constitutions and interrupting early voting and ignoring their Supreme Courts all together. We know based on that, Republicans would explore every single option possible to move this forward.....
In an interview on Friday night, before his Saturday meeting with Virginia lawmakers, Mr. Jeffries said he was exploring how to unravel this decision.
Its an all-hands-on-deck moment, and its unprecedented in American history as far as we can tell that an actual election has been overturned by a handful of unelected judges, Mr. Jeffries said. Were not going to step back, we will continue to fight back.
This is a very aggressive plan which could backfire. However, this plan may be necessary to stop trump's gerrymandering.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
9 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
53 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Furious Democrats Reportedly Float Dramatic Idea:Throwing Out Virginia's Supreme Court to Push Through Gerrymandered map [View all]
BumRushDaShow
Sunday
OP
I'm equally angry, but is there no alternative solution? This freaks me out--especially with the timing.
hlthe2b
Sunday
#2
A Private Call Reveals Democrats' Desperation Over Tossing of Map (NYT gift article)
LetMyPeopleVote
Sunday
#3
My thinking, Give the Virginia SC ONE warning that this is what will be done if they refuse. BUT
bluestarone
Sunday
#7
If they fucking refuse what? They already made their fucking horseshit ruling. Warning time is motherfucking over.
SoFlaBro
20 hrs ago
#53
When republicans pull similar actions to combat Democrats, their members don't worry about it, they just do it.
MLWR
Sunday
#8
Think about what happens if we let the GOP redistricting advantage cost us the House.
SamuelAdams
Sunday
#12
Dems eye 'audacious' secret plan to oust entire blue state Supreme Court: report
LetMyPeopleVote
Sunday
#13
Bottom line, if Democrats have any political courage at all, they will tear it down and then rebuild
PatrickforB
Sunday
#14
Extraordinary times require extraordinary measures. If we don't take the house back in November, we lose our demcracy.
Fil1957
Sunday
#20
This isn't the first time that a constitutional amendment passed by voters was overturned by courts.
MichMan
Yesterday
#44
Trump Wins Big as Virginia Dems Won't Go Nuclear to Save 4 House Seats
LetMyPeopleVote
Yesterday
#50