Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LetMyPeopleVote

(175,781 posts)
25. Maddow Blog-House Republicans pass the 'SAVE Act,' which is a solution in search of a problem
Thu Apr 10, 2025, 04:29 PM
Apr 2025

Last edited Thu Apr 10, 2025, 05:39 PM - Edit history (1)

I volunteer on voting rights/voter protection efforts. Non-citizens do not vote
 
The House GOP majority passed a ban on noncitizen voting, which (a) almost never happens; and (b) is already illegal. It’s worth understanding why.

The SAVE Act would:
- make it harder for Americans to vote
- address a problem that doesn't exist
- impose new burdens on state election administrators

House Republicans passed it anyway. www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...

Steve Benen (@stevebenen.com) 2025-04-10T19:49:50.489Z

The SAVE Act would:
- make it harder for Americans to vote
- address a problem that doesn't exist
- impose new burdens on state election administrators

House Republicans passed it anyway.



https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/house-republicans-pass-act-solution-search-problem-rcna200681

The GOP duo pitched legislation that would require documentary proof of citizenship to register to vote. The absurdity of watching two notorious election deniers pretend to be deeply concerned with the integrity of elections was a detail the political world was apparently supposed to overlook.

Soon after, House Republicans followed through, introducing the “Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act” (or “SAVE Act”). As NBC News reported, that same bill has now passed the chamber.

The legislation, sponsored by Rep. Chip Roy, R-Texas, would amend the National Voter Registration Act so that states would be required to obtain proof of citizenship in person from people who are registering to vote. It would also require states to establish a program to remove undocumented immigrants from existing voter rolls and would allow American citizens to sue election officials that don’t follow proof of citizenship requirements.


The measure cleared the chamber on a 220-208 vote, with four Democrats — Reps. Ed Case of Hawaii; Henry Cuellar of Texas; Jared Golden of Maine; and Marie Gluesenkamp Perez of Washington — voting with the majority. No GOP members opposed the bill.

The principal concern with the legislation is that it’s a solution in search of a problem. To hear Republicans tell it, policymakers must prevent noncitizens from voting, which probably sounds reasonable. In fact, it’s so reasonable that the SAVE Act is redundant: There are literally zero locations in the United States where noncitizens can vote in federal and/or state elections.

GOP lawmakers have also argued that legislation is needed to curtail the scourge of noncitizens who are already voting. Except, Republicans have gone searching for evidence of this problem and found effectively nothing.....

What’s more, as The Associated Press reported last month, state elections officials — from both parties — have expressed practical concerns about how these costly proposed procedures would be implemented and paid for. The same article added, “Voting rights groups have said married women who have changed their name could have trouble registering under the SAVE Act because their birth certificate lists their maiden name.”....

The bill now heads to the Senate, where Republican Sen. Mike Lee of Utah is championing a companion bill. The odds of the legislation overcoming a Democratic filibuster, however, are poor. Watch this space.

During the Texas voter id litigation back in 2012, Greg Abbott as AG argued that non-citizens were voting but could provide no evidence of this because non-citizens are too scared to break the law by voting

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

We'll have elections in 2026, but there will be a heavy thumb on the scale HereForTheParty Apr 2025 #1
An Iron Fist on the scale thought crime Apr 2025 #17
They really want revenge for 2020, don't they? Initech Apr 2025 #2
The Dems actually will need to support this, but.... Falcon101 Apr 2025 #3
Wow your REAL ID doesn't even count? That is freaking terrible and stupid. AZJonnie Apr 2025 #6
The Guardian says Real IDs that indicate if the applicant is a U.S. Citizen will work - but most don't. Earthrise Apr 2025 #11
You have to provide your birth certificate Deminpenn Apr 2025 #13
Also picture IDs? thought crime Apr 2025 #18
No you don't have to have a photo ID to get a REAL ID, technically AZJonnie Apr 2025 #22
PennDOT also does the photo IDs Deminpenn Apr 2025 #31
WATCH: What to know about REAL ID and when you'll need it - PBS NewsHour: Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #33
We have seen the last fair and meaningful election in US history Miguelito Loveless Apr 2025 #4
To vote you have to be a registered voter and to be that you have to be a U.S. citizen for all Federal Elections Botany Apr 2025 #5
Whenever the Gop are in trouble, they always make it harder to vote Mr. Sparkle Apr 2025 #7
Next week/month Republicans will be voting to BAN voting by mail in Federal elections Bengus81 Apr 2025 #23
They know they have to cheat to "win" Rhiannon12866 Apr 2025 #32
The 4 Dems who voted for this should be primaried! LostOne4Ever Apr 2025 #8
Especially the female one, Marie G Perez, WA-3 IzzaNuDay Apr 2025 #24
DOA in the Senate? maxsolomon Apr 2025 #9
Yeah Polybius Apr 2025 #15
You didn't get blasted by me. maxsolomon Apr 2025 #20
Then you can reimburse me for expenses and time otchmoson Apr 2025 #10
I'm thinking lots of over seas ballots are gonna be thrown out. bluestarone Apr 2025 #12
How many undocumented immigrants are on LoisB Apr 2025 #14
No matter...looks like deportation is part of the plan. n/t BadgerKid Apr 2025 #16
I still don't know why Buffet or Cuban, or Gates, Oprah.... don't fund an ID supply drive LiberalLovinLug Apr 2025 #19
Similarly, I was just thinking about asking my local party what we can do to help people ... Alice B. Apr 2025 #26
Quick Republicans...show us all the thousands/millions of illegals caught voting. Bengus81 Apr 2025 #21
Maddow Blog-House Republicans pass the 'SAVE Act,' which is a solution in search of a problem LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2025 #25
Papers please. Birth certificate, passport, Real ID not good enough bucolic_frolic Apr 2025 #27
Marc Elias on House republicans trying try disenfranchise millions of voters LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2025 #28
Marc Elias on House republicans trying try disenfranchise millions of voters LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2025 #29
I don't get it Bluestocking Apr 2025 #30
No Polybius Apr 2025 #34
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»House passes bill requiri...»Reply #25