Latest Breaking News

Raven123

(6,306 posts)

9. Here is a link to a more detailed discussion

Wed Jan 22, 2025, 04:33 PM

Jan 22

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-1/section-5/clause-4/adjournment-of-congress

In his Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States, Justice Joseph Story reasoned that by empowering Congress to determine when to adjourn, the Framers prevented the President from using the royal governor tactic of squelching dissent by adjourning colonial legislatures.6 Consequently, Article I, Section 5, Clause 4 checked the President’s power over Congress.7 Likewise, by requiring the two chambers of Congress to agree to any adjournment longer than three days, Clause 4 prevented either house from frustrating the legislative process by adjourning. In addition, by authorizing the President to resolve disagreements between the two chambers on when they would adjourn, the Framers created an incentive for the chambers to cooperate.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

raging moderate Unwind Your Mind IthinkThereforeIAM wyn borkins

57 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Trump warns he'll adjourn Congress to make recess appointments. How would that work? [View all] BumRushDaShow Jan 22 OP

Unbelievable DownriverDem Jan 22 #1

Per the Constitution Raven123 Jan 22 #3

But there is a loophole provision - normally reserved for "extraordinary" situations BumRushDaShow Jan 22 #7

Yes. Thanks. I added a similar post later. Raven123 Jan 22 #11

I expect the SCOTUS would punt BumRushDaShow Jan 22 #12

Another thought to consider Raven123 Jan 22 #15

Well Wilson was also in office during WWI BumRushDaShow Jan 22 #18

I think we know where Trump got his playbook Raven123 Jan 22 #19

Well we here in Philly BumRushDaShow Jan 22 #21

Wilson also seggretrated the civil service. IbogaProject Jan 22 #45

Trump has already declared two national emergencies. (border and energy) LudwigPastorius Jan 22 #31

He is not Charles I of England and the US Congress is not Parliament. wnylib Jan 23 #48

That only says the President can adjourn Congress VMA131Marine Jan 22 #34

"That only says the President can adjourn Congress if the House and Senate disagree" BumRushDaShow Jan 23 #49

The Constitution is also quite clear birdographer Jan 22 #10

So, dictator from day 1 to forever. NotHardly Jan 23 #57

He cannot dissolve or adjourn Congress pfitz59 Jan 22 #2

Democrats had better kacekwl Jan 22 #4

See my post upthread BumRushDaShow Jan 22 #8

Start the impeachment process. Then follow it up with another one for Vance. Rinse and repeat. chowder66 Jan 22 #5

Charles I dissolved Parliament, claiming he could rule Ocelot II Jan 22 #6

Here is a link to a more detailed discussion Raven123 Jan 22 #9

I'm hoping for a way out ... what won't be an "extraordinary occassion"? BadgerKid Jan 22 #13

I'll ask again, "Who is going to stop him" ? republianmushroom Jan 22 #14

Well there's always the Supreme Cour...... Ha ha ha ha ha Ray Bruns Jan 23 #53

I understand. republianmushroom Jan 23 #55

While I'm sure Trump would want to do it right now jgmiller Jan 22 #16

How would this actually work? jgmiller Jan 22 #17

MMW... there is a line he will cross & this sh*t will blow up. NotHardly Jan 22 #20

Excellent point jgmiller Jan 22 #22

Still hard to believe the rethugs continue to roll over for this bloviating, lying... brush Jan 22 #29

Perhaps WestMichRad Jan 22 #23

He said he was going to be a dictator Blue_Tires Jan 22 #24

I'm not going to believe him. He doesn't have a clue. Martin68 Jan 22 #26

He is surrounded by thousands who do. Evolve Dammit Jan 23 #50

Wait until he ignores an adverse ruling from a federal judge VMA131Marine Jan 22 #36

He's already done that before Blue_Tires Jan 22 #39

The supreme court has no enforcement power. "Has neither purse nor sword." PSPS Jan 22 #43

And even if they did Blue_Tires Jan 22 #46

That's just Trump talking out of his ass. 90% of whaat he says is meaningless. Martin68 Jan 22 #25

All Trump needs to do is pull Republican congressional leaders into his office DBoon Jan 22 #27

We are dealing with a mob boss. Absolutely true. Trust_Reality Jan 22 #35

Following This Thread Baron2024 Jan 22 #28

He can't just rule by decree Diraven Jan 22 #30

He Might Try To Though Baron2024 Jan 22 #32

Congress can just come back Diraven Jan 22 #33

Okay Baron2024 Jan 22 #37

What legal basis? VMA131Marine Jan 22 #38

Okay Baron2024 Jan 22 #40

The President cannot spend money not appropriated by Congress VMA131Marine Jan 22 #41

Right Baron2024 Jan 22 #42

Congress Baron2024 Jan 22 #44

How does it work? Simple. He orders Thune and Johnson to shut down. Congress adjourns. Marcuse Jan 23 #47

If and when he shuts down Congress might he prefer to keep them out of the picture?? NoMoreRepugs Jan 23 #51

Water Please the Show is About to get Real for Donald J. Trump Oneear Jan 23 #52

"warns" (the headline) is different than "threatens" (the story) LastLiberal in PalmSprings Jan 23 #54

Been saying from Day 1 Owens Jan 23 #56