Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Sympthsical

(11,262 posts)
5. It's crazy it went to trial
Tue Jun 9, 2026, 07:07 PM
Jun 9

He was so thoroughly and obviously guilty. There were 24 witnesses basically all telling coherent stories that aligned with the physical and video evidence. The people whose stories varied wildly in the media were disproved with evidence, and they changed their tunes real quick once on the stand with perjury being a thing that exists.

When even the defense's own witnesses were on the stand going, "Yeah, he's pretty much guilty," his goose was cooked.

I still can't believe it even went to trial. He and his family seem to have gotten rotten advice from the start. There should have been a plea, and then this young man could serve his sentence for the tragedy he caused and still have the bulk of his life ahead of him.

I don't know if they were getting all gassed up from social media or what, but the prosecutors barely had to try here, and the defense literally had nothing. It was frankly weird to see just how little they had in way of defense, and yet it still went to trial.

I do think he regrets it. All the testimony that came after signifies that. If they ultimately go with 20 years, I think that would be just given things. But that's up to the jury.

Justice was done. Two lives wasted. TheProle Jun 9 #1
Only three Manatee Jun 9 #2
This was justice. Melon Jun 9 #3
I still can't believe there were no African Americans on the damn jury!!!!! a kennedy Jun 9 #4
I saw a report that they were struck due to all being educators MichMan Jun 9 #7
that makes no sense at all dsc Jun 9 #13
The defense struck as well Melon Jun 9 #14
It was reported that a common refrain from the black voir dire members Seeking Serenity Jun 9 #21
Or they just didn't want to be selected is another possibility MichMan Jun 10 #22
Well, indeed. I always liked the George Carlin strategy for getting on juries Seeking Serenity Jun 10 #26
I believe you are referring to the black prospective jurors that were struck for cause. Ilikepurple Jun 10 #24
I bristle when I hear it was "an all-white jury" Seeking Serenity Jun 10 #27
It's crazy it went to trial Sympthsical Jun 9 #5
Family Para722 Jun 9 #6
His family was a bunch of grifters Melon Jun 9 #11
It very well could have been the case that the defense attorney was encouraging Anthony to accept a plea deal Seeking Serenity Jun 9 #19
Even if he gets 25 or even 30 years, he still might "still have the bulk of his life ahead of him" Polybius Jun 9 #8
His parole officer hasn't been born yet... Melon Jun 9 #12
This was pretty clear cut. BlueTsunami2018 Jun 9 #9
35 year Manatee Jun 9 #10
and how did you hear of DU??? a kennedy Jun 9 #15
A very kind neighbor told me about DU Manatee Jun 9 #16
Thanks to your neighbor, welcome, and hope he'll be out in 17 years. a kennedy Jun 9 #17
She's a wonderful lady Manatee Jun 9 #18
Since The Penalty Has Been Set At 35 Years, Opinions As To.. ColoringFool Jun 10 #29
I've heard it explained that it's exceptionally rare for someone convicted of murder Seeking Serenity Jun 9 #20
"Hope he'll be out in seventeen years"?! Llewlladdwr Jun 10 #23
WHY? He Carried A Deadly Weapon Into A Sporting Event. At Age 36, ColoringFool Jun 10 #30
This is just Blue_Roses Jun 10 #25
HE WAS SENTENCED TO 35 YEARS IN PRISON. THIS ARTICLE'S "5 YEARS...." IS WRONG. ColoringFool Jun 10 #28
At the time it was written,, the sentence had not yet been determined. MichMan Jun 10 #32
Hmph. Looking back at Rittenhouse,, Zimmerman, Chan.etc... IzzaNuDay Jun 10 #31
Different cases, different evidence, different juries MichMan Jun 10 #33
Well...he killed a kid by stabbing him in the chest Melon Jun 12 #34
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Karmelo Anthony found gui...»Reply #5