Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,630 posts)
50. People often treat publications in the scientific literature as if they were a kind of gospel.
Fri Feb 6, 2026, 02:04 PM
Feb 6

I couldn't possibly count the number of times I've heard here and elsewhere the confusion between the term "peer reviewed" and the word "truth." They're are not synonymous by any means.

I sometimes post links to articles from the wonderful website Retraction Watch. (I recently posted over in the science forum a link to an article from that discussed the link between pregnancy and performance in mathematics. )

The scientific literature, like all human discourse, particularly in the age of the internet and now AI, is increasingly polluted. None of this is said to invalidate or impugn anything about the science or the scientists whose work you have referenced, but only to note that all responses to information require critical thinking.

Scientists, even great scientists, can be, and often are, wrong. It is widely held, and in my opinion, correctly widely accepted that Albert Einstein was wrong in almost all of his scientific arguments with his good friend Neils Bohr. This in no way impugn Einstein of course.

I have not read the article you cited, am not familiar with institution or the authors. I have only skimmed your headline.

Over the years here I've gotten a lot of negative pushback with respect to my opinions on pot. It's gotten so that I often don't want to be involved in it.

I can say this: Brain size does not correlate well with brain performance. This is well known. No one expects that if we hooked up a being with opposable thumbs and additional digits to an elephant's brain the result would produce genius. Brain swelling can and often does degrade brain function.

I wish I could say that I am unfamiliar with the consequences of pot use and - at the risk of generating DU outrage - pot addiction, but I'm not. On this basis I cannot applaud its use. This is not to say that I favor criminal sanctions against pot, only that I do not favor use.

I can usually expect that someone will pipe in that alcohol use is worse than pot use.

The logic of this statement is similar to making a statement that since pancreatic cancer is worse than breast cancer, having breast cancer is OK.

I'm unimpressed with the "alcohol is worse" argument.

To be clear, although alcohol can be bad for one, I will enjoy a glass or two of champagne when the orange pedophile in the White House shuffles off his mortal coil and faces "what dreams may come" as Shakespeare had Hamlet saying about kicking off.

May we be drinking our bubbly soon...

Thanks, as always, my friend.



Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

You may want to investigate your allergy further EYESORE 9001 Feb 6 #1
Yeah, smoke carries many allergens that are the products of combustion. Hugin Feb 6 #2
Other forms work just as well Blue Full Moon Feb 6 #16
I find this quite encouraging! slightlv Feb 6 #17
Yeah, I never smoke it. But I take it in gummy form. Wednesdays Feb 6 #25
Which helps with cognitive improvement. Blue Full Moon Feb 6 #55
My allergies are extensive. But I never had any interest in it anyway, so niyad Feb 6 #3
No wonder rednecks are vehemently against legalization SheltieLover Feb 6 #4
Yes, of course! niyad Feb 6 #6
At least until they figure out how to grift it. SheltieLover Feb 6 #11
Exactly!!! niyad Feb 6 #28
You'd be surprised how many rednecks smoke pot. More likely to be Christian fundamentalists who oppose legalization. Martin68 Feb 6 #38
Yes they do. But will not legalize it, unless they profit SheltieLover Feb 6 #39
Here's a link to an article about the study, from NORML: intheflow Feb 6 #5
Thank you for the link. niyad Feb 6 #7
You can try this one JudyM Feb 6 #9
Thank you for these links. They all work for me. niyad Feb 6 #30
Thank you for the link! Interesting and easy to read! slightlv Feb 6 #18
Is it 4 20 yet? But there's that short term memory issue....what were we talking about? surfered Feb 6 #8
I've been conducting decades of research on this topic as well. tritsofme Feb 6 #10
Funny, I've observed the opposite of others that I know. Zackzzzz Feb 6 #14
I'e noticed the same Mossfern Feb 6 #40
Same here.. and I also agree. mountain grammy Feb 6 #26
Difficult to wrap my head around the fact we are still having to argue for the right to smoke a weed SheltieLover Feb 6 #12
I so agree with you! slightlv Feb 6 #20
Don't smoke a joint, just spray round up on food & eat it SheltieLover Feb 7 #66
Eh, not once one learns about that dreaded and insidious practice that has been a thorn in our society's side... OldBaldy1701E Feb 7 #64
Yup SheltieLover Feb 7 #65
Never had memory lapses with cannabis... MiHale Feb 6 #13
I also never had memory lapses with cannabis... Towlie Feb 6 #53
Congratulations on "being stuck with your current brain." NNadir Feb 6 #15
Well, not certain about the "not broke" part, given the horror show niyad Feb 6 #44
People often treat publications in the scientific literature as if they were a kind of gospel. NNadir Feb 6 #50
I used to think that certain journals, magazines, etc., were at least niyad Feb 7 #58
It makes me paranoid. ananda Feb 6 #19
A heavy dose does the same to me, so I don't Ilsa Feb 6 #29
One side effect for me was out-of-body experiences. ananda Feb 6 #54
The minute I retire, gummy use starts before bed. roamer65 Feb 6 #21
An ounce of prevention ..... H2O Man Feb 6 #22
Psst...don't tell Governor Kevin Stitt of Oklahoma Wednesdays Feb 6 #23
shitt. .errrr, stitt, is a waste of oxygen. niyad Feb 6 #32
Pot, brain and pain reliever maliaSmith Feb 6 #24
I know a number of people who cook and bake with cannabis butter. niyad Feb 6 #36
The larger brain volume will be helpful for thinking about curing the lung disease Renew Deal Feb 6 #27
Ever hear of edibles? Warpy Feb 6 #35
Hi Niyad, I'm one of those weird people immune to THC Coventina Feb 6 #31
You are immune. .I am allergic. What a pair we are! niyad Feb 6 #33
I always knew you were special!! Coventina Feb 6 #34
As are you!!! niyad Feb 6 #45
Learning another language can be your brain's best buddy! GreenWave Feb 6 #37
Or doing crossword puzzles, other word games! niyad Feb 6 #46
Thank you! I have been laughed at for over 50 years because I'm allergic to pot also. txwhitedove Feb 6 #41
You are most welcome. Not sure I was laughed at, since people niyad Feb 6 #47
Let me know when Hopkins or UCLA say the same, thanks. Ford_Prefect Feb 6 #42
See post 9 for a link to the actual study. I have no idea where niyad Feb 6 #48
I have found Codifer Feb 6 #43
Coffee, or wine (depending on time of day), chocolate, cat on lap, niyad Feb 6 #49
Cat on keyboard. Codifer Feb 6 #51
Understand completely. niyad Feb 6 #56
Thanks for posting canetoad Feb 6 #52
You are most welcome. Happy if I can help. niyad Feb 6 #57
"Clearly, more research is needed" - I completely agree. On it, right away. 0rganism Feb 7 #59
Enjoy your research. niyad Feb 7 #62
For science! 0rganism Feb 7 #67
It's true - i was high and I finally grasped the concept of... lame54 Feb 7 #60
The possibility of life in the Crab Nebula. niyad Feb 7 #61
Oh yeah. The definitive proof is... lame54 Feb 7 #63
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"Cannabis leads to larger...»Reply #50