MaddowBlog-It's not just ICE: A debate over breaking up the Department of Homeland Security begins [View all]
After seeing Trump-era abuses, one department veteran said, It makes me think that maybe DHS was a bad idea.
https://www.ms.now/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/its-not-just-ice-a-debate-over-breaking-up-the-department-of-homeland-security-begins
Miles Taylor, who served as the Department of Homeland Securitys chief of staff during Donald Trumps first term, told MS NOW last week that he now believes th
e Republican president has done irreparable damage to the department. Taylor told Nicolle Wallace on Deadline: White House that
he had resisted calling for the dismantling of DHS, but hes recently come around to the idea that its necessary.
Hes not alone. The Atlantic recently published a good report on the debate over the departments future. It quoted Seth Stodder, who worked for Customs and Border Protection under George W. Bush and the DHS under Barack Obama. After seeing Trump-era abuses, Stodder concluded, It makes me think that maybe DHS was a bad idea.
Ben Rhodes, a veteran of the Obama White House, wrote an op-ed for The New York Times not only endorsing systemic DHS reforms, but also explaining how its powers can and should be reshuffled in the federal deck. From Rhodes piece:
The rot goes deeper at the Department of Homeland Security, the behemoth that controls ICE, Customs and Border Protection (C.B.P.) and myriad other federal agencies, from the Federal Emergency Management Agency to the Secret Service. Since its founding in 2002, a combination of organizational flaws and mission creep has allowed D.H.S. to evolve into the out-of-control domestic security apparatus we have today, one that views the very people it is supposed to protect as threats, not humans.
In the immediate aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, Congress and the Bush/Cheney administration believed it was necessary to create a new federal department focused on domestic security. The result was a mishmash of existing agencies and offices that were thrown together.....
Its hardly unreasonable to think the nation is due for a conversation about whether structural reforms are needed, especially as DHS struggles badly with its overwhelming responsibilities.
Rhodes op-ed added,
Unwinding this will take time and is unlikely during the Trump administration. But the time to start this debate is now. Dont be surprised if some aspiring Democratic presidential candidates start to focus on this debate in the coming months and years.