Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

cab67

(3,656 posts)
5. Reminds me of what I learned reading Autumn of the Black Snake.
Sat Nov 29, 2025, 12:13 PM
Nov 29

The book covers the history of the Northwest Indian War ("Little Turtle's War " ) of the 1790's.

The framers of the constitution didn't want a large standing army. They feared a despotic leader could use such an army for their own purposes. (Smart fellows, these framers.) That was the main reason the second amendment was put there - the idea was that common people, especially those on the frontier who might encounter Indigenous Americans or British units unhappy with their presence, would form a local militia with their own arms and serve the purpose of a regular army.

They wouldn't have artillery - the regular army would provide that - but the small arms used by the average citizen were basically the same as what a trained soldier would have. Maybe they had more rifled muskets, but these were far slower to load at the time, so they didn't necessarily give a rifleman an advantage.

This proved disastrous in practice. We didn't have an enormous standing army until after the Second World War, but the standing army was expanded in the years after this war.

It's an excellent book.

Recommendations

8 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

K&R Hugin Nov 29 #1
Thanks... BH liberal Nov 29 #2
My brother was in the NYNG for 14yrs Historic NY Nov 29 #3
I took basic training at Fort Lewis, WA... BH liberal Nov 29 #6
Jebus. Irish_Dem Nov 29 #4
Yes... BH liberal Nov 29 #7
Reminds me of what I learned reading Autumn of the Black Snake. cab67 Nov 29 #5
Thanks for your book recommendo... BH liberal Nov 29 #9
Interesting Sequoia Nov 29 #18
ONLY ONE REASON to deploy the Guards here. To help people and save lives. usonian Nov 29 #8
Well said! BH liberal Nov 29 #10
The Coast Guard has deployed overseas to Bahrain. Shipwack Nov 29 #19
That's why they are now being paired with DC Police for protection. SunSeeker Nov 29 #11
So true! BH liberal Nov 29 #13
Deployed NEEDLESSLY. BurnDoubt Nov 29 #12
It's clear... BH liberal Nov 29 #14
Enlightening KT2000 Nov 29 #15
You're welcome. As experiences go, BH liberal Nov 29 #17
I appreciated your writing KT2000 Nov 29 #20
KNR. niyad Nov 29 #16
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»One of the main reasons w...»Reply #5