General Discussion

NickB79

(20,278 posts)

36. One eye witness claimed there was NAVAL fire

Mon Jun 2, 2025, 02:45 PM

Jun 2025

https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2025/jun/01/palestinians-killed-food-distribution-gaza-strip-israel-middle-east-crisis-live

“There was fire from all directions, from naval warships, from tanks and drones,” said Amr Abu Teiba, who was in the crowd.

The nearest naval ship was 4 miles away, and this "eye witness" had absolutely no way of seeing an Israeli ship from his location 🤦

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

67 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

"WATCH: GHF proves IDF did not shoot at innocent Gazans at aid distribution sites" [View all] madaboutharry Jun 2025 OP

So how do you describe what's going on in Gaza? IMO there does seem to be some inhumane dying and... brush Jun 2025 #1

There does. But not at the food distribution center today. Reports of violence there, as the OP shows, were fake. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #6

Food shortages in Gaza did not begin today and it's nothing but obvious that... brush Jun 2025 #23

Your deflection notwithstanding, my post was very explicit and specific. It has to do with the OP and not Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #24

You're saying the default to many is to blame Israel. I purposely... brush Jun 2025 #25

In case you are still unsure how your posts deflect to Israel: Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #30

Again, I blame warmonger Netanyahu. brush Jun 2025 #31

This response is completely inadequate in addressing the issue at hand. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #32

I knew you weren't all bad. You share my thoughts on Netanyahu. brush Jun 2025 #34

At least 31 people killed, 175 wounded. It's a massacre. AloeVera Jun 2025 #2

That didn't age well, did it? Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #4

Well said. 👍 Dave Bowman Jun 2025 #27

That is not much in the way of proof. Eko Jun 2025 #3

Where is the proof of violence happening there? Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #7

Where did I claim that? You are fond of strawman. Eko Jun 2025 #9

That was a rhetorical question. Of course I don't expect you to come up with any proof. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #12

You literally asked me this "Where is the proof of violence happening there?" Eko Jun 2025 #13

This message was self-deleted by its author Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #14

Yes I did. I literally asked you that question. And I expected you to have no answer to it. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #15

Just want to remind you that your rhetorical question was of a position I had not taken. Eko Jun 2025 #16

But you did take a position. A position I rhetorically questioned. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #18

The position I took was that your evidence was not much. Eko Jun 2025 #35

So you did take a position after all. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #59

My position is Eko Jun 2025 #67

Mahalo for this, mad. I believe it. Cha Jun 2025 #5

The most likely cause of the bullet-riddled corpses is an attack by Hamas after the aid was distributed NickB79 Jun 2025 #8

Eyewitnesses contradict that. AloeVera Jun 2025 #17

Proof? Mountainguy Jun 2025 #21

One eye witness claimed there was NAVAL fire NickB79 Jun 2025 #36

So the IDF gunned down dozens of Palestinians at 4am, but then gave out food at 6am? NickB79 Jun 2025 #37

Well.. AloeVera Jun 2025 #38

The thought of a well-fed hamas terrorist ordering about and shooting and stealing from his own people Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #46

The report I saw said it wasn't clear who did the shooting iemanja Jun 2025 #10

Additionally, a Google news search shows only WaPo and AL Jazeera claiming the shooters were Israeli iemanja Jun 2025 #11

Gaza Humanitarian Foundation is controversial thought crime Jun 2025 #19

No, it wasn't Mountainguy Jun 2025 #22

Only if you ignore 70-80 or a hundred Palestinian deaths...then it was peachy. AloeVera Jun 2025 #47

Provide proof the IDF shot them while seeking aid Mountainguy Jun 2025 #48

Don't have to. AloeVera Jun 2025 #49

So you dont know who shot them Mountainguy Jun 2025 #50

Sniped in the head and chest. Died from tank shrapnel. AloeVera Jun 2025 #52

Proof? Mountainguy Jun 2025 #53

Red Cross field hospital. AloeVera Jun 2025 #57

I DID google it. Why didn't YOU? Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #61

Doesn't prove anything Mountainguy Jun 2025 #66

Also see post #62. It was the IDF. AloeVera Jun 2025 #63

No, it was CNN, not IDF Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #65

Machine guns that the IDF has, and Hamas doesn't muriel_volestrangler Jun 2025 #54

So he admits he cant identify the weapon or who fired it Mountainguy Jun 2025 #55

They are attached to tanks. muriel_volestrangler Jun 2025 #56

No weapons, no tanks, no weapons attached to tanks. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #58

This message was self-deleted by its author thought crime Jun 2025 #20

Media never learn, do they? mcar Jun 2025 #26

What kind of person obsesses about defending war crimes over and over? Johnny2X2X Jun 2025 #28

Are you referring to the OP? Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #41

Trying really hard to Re writing history Blue Full Moon Jun 2025 #29

By showing the actual surveillance camera footage? Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #40

There is a vocal group Mountainguy Jun 2025 #51

The GHF..... has the backing of the Trump administration and the Israeli government. .... Ping Tung Jun 2025 #33

Neither one of your statements makes a dent in contesting the accuracy of the OP. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #39

My post says that the Trump administration and the Israeli government back the GHF. Ping Tung Jun 2025 #42

It's true, but it's is as relevant to the OP as stating that the Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #43

I find itr very relevant to know the OP's source for his ovservations. Ping Tung Jun 2025 #44

The source for the OP's observation is the security camera recording the event as it happened. Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #45

This message was self-deleted by its author AloeVera Jun 2025 #60

It was the IDF, per CNN investigation published today. AloeVera Jun 2025 #62

And further into the article: Beastly Boy Jun 2025 #64