Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: I can't help but feel like a failure [View all]Celerity
(47,542 posts)15. It is extremely unlikely we take back the Senate in 2026 (and 2028 looks grim as well, especially if we do not do well
in 2026).
I am usually very accurate with my Senate picks. IF Casey (PA) had won in 2024, I would have called every single race correctly.
Even if we sweep the 6 remotely close races in 2026 (plus win a potential wild card loss tossed in, in VA, see below), we would only get to 50-50 (and thus Vance breaks ties)
In terms of Rethugs at risk in 2026 (potentially 3):
NC (Tillis is by far our best chance to flip a seat Red to Blue, unless Collins retires in ME. Roy Cooper hopefully runs. Jeff Jackson also may run, but he just was elected NC AG. US ex US House Representative (he retired this year as he knew he would lose his redistricted seat) Wiley Nickel will likely run, but he was one of the most conservative Dems in the House, and would be the most conservative Dem US Senator unless Golden of ME (see below) runs and wins. That said, obviously Nickel would be FAR better than any Rethug.)
ME (IF Collins retires, we very likely flip it, but if she runs, we will have a real dog fight on our hands. We have a real problem in ME with turncoat Dem voters defecting and voting for the POS Collins, she has brainwashed far too many of them into thinking she is true moderate. Stephen King was by far our best shot in 2020, but I doubt he runs. He refused to run in 2020, and in 2027 he turns 80yo. ME Governor Janet Mills also turns 80 in 2027. Chellie Pingree turns 72 in 2027, and she was beaten badly by Collins the last time she ran against her. Our best 2 candiates are probably the recently term limited ME State Senate leader Troy Jackson, but he may run for Governor to replace Mills, and then Jared Golden. That said, IF Golden wins, he very likely becomes the most conservative Democratric US Senator. Golden, Marie Gluesenkamp Perez of WA, plus Henry Cuellar of TX (in deep legal trouble atm) are the 3 most conservative US House Dems left, even more than Suozzi from NY. That said, Golden of course would be better than Collins or any other Rethug).
KY (McTurtle is very very likely done and dusted, and Andy Beshear is by far our best hope, BUT KY (like several other Red states) is so hard to get a Dem Senator elected in. Even popular Dem Governors (like Beshear) struggle to make the leap, plus Beshear has said he does not want to run for the US Seante in 2026) Beshear is, unfortunately, the only KY Dem who would have a real shot.
We have 3 seats at risk, and one wild card, in 2026:
GA Jon Ossoff
MI Gary Peters
NH Jeanne Shaheen
VA (wild card...... IF Mark Warner retires and Youngkin runs)
In 2028 the Rethugs only have 2 seats at actual risk (one more than the other)
WI Ron Johnson (the most likely for us to flip)
NC Ted Budd (but he is far more popular than Tillis)
I simply do not see us having real shots at flipping a Senate seat in Red FL or Red OH.
We have to defend 5 seats that are at risk in 2028:
AZ Mark Kelly
GA Raphael Warnock
PA John Fetterman
NV Catherine Cortez Masto
NH Maggie Hassan
I am usually very accurate with my Senate picks. IF Casey (PA) had won in 2024, I would have called every single race correctly.
Even if we sweep the 6 remotely close races in 2026 (plus win a potential wild card loss tossed in, in VA, see below), we would only get to 50-50 (and thus Vance breaks ties)
In terms of Rethugs at risk in 2026 (potentially 3):
NC (Tillis is by far our best chance to flip a seat Red to Blue, unless Collins retires in ME. Roy Cooper hopefully runs. Jeff Jackson also may run, but he just was elected NC AG. US ex US House Representative (he retired this year as he knew he would lose his redistricted seat) Wiley Nickel will likely run, but he was one of the most conservative Dems in the House, and would be the most conservative Dem US Senator unless Golden of ME (see below) runs and wins. That said, obviously Nickel would be FAR better than any Rethug.)
ME (IF Collins retires, we very likely flip it, but if she runs, we will have a real dog fight on our hands. We have a real problem in ME with turncoat Dem voters defecting and voting for the POS Collins, she has brainwashed far too many of them into thinking she is true moderate. Stephen King was by far our best shot in 2020, but I doubt he runs. He refused to run in 2020, and in 2027 he turns 80yo. ME Governor Janet Mills also turns 80 in 2027. Chellie Pingree turns 72 in 2027, and she was beaten badly by Collins the last time she ran against her. Our best 2 candiates are probably the recently term limited ME State Senate leader Troy Jackson, but he may run for Governor to replace Mills, and then Jared Golden. That said, IF Golden wins, he very likely becomes the most conservative Democratric US Senator. Golden, Marie Gluesenkamp Perez of WA, plus Henry Cuellar of TX (in deep legal trouble atm) are the 3 most conservative US House Dems left, even more than Suozzi from NY. That said, Golden of course would be better than Collins or any other Rethug).
KY (McTurtle is very very likely done and dusted, and Andy Beshear is by far our best hope, BUT KY (like several other Red states) is so hard to get a Dem Senator elected in. Even popular Dem Governors (like Beshear) struggle to make the leap, plus Beshear has said he does not want to run for the US Seante in 2026) Beshear is, unfortunately, the only KY Dem who would have a real shot.
We have 3 seats at risk, and one wild card, in 2026:
GA Jon Ossoff
MI Gary Peters
NH Jeanne Shaheen
VA (wild card...... IF Mark Warner retires and Youngkin runs)
In 2028 the Rethugs only have 2 seats at actual risk (one more than the other)
WI Ron Johnson (the most likely for us to flip)
NC Ted Budd (but he is far more popular than Tillis)
I simply do not see us having real shots at flipping a Senate seat in Red FL or Red OH.
We have to defend 5 seats that are at risk in 2028:
AZ Mark Kelly
GA Raphael Warnock
PA John Fetterman
NV Catherine Cortez Masto
NH Maggie Hassan
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
12 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
61 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
It is extremely unlikely we take back the Senate in 2026 (and 2028 looks grim as well, especially if we do not do well
Celerity
Jan 12
#15
I think Vance is our next worry. He's smart and ruthless. I'm worried about things to come...
CTyankee
Jan 12
#35
Maybe, but potayto-potahto at this point. If they are pretending, it is only validating him more to the public
In It to Win It
Jan 12
#8
Careful. "Vermin", when applied to people, reminds us how the Nazis dehumanized jews by calling them vermin. . . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Jan 12
#14
They are irrational to some degree, but they are human beings, not vermin, not sub-human, not to be killed on sight. nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Jan 12
#44
Then people should not be called vermin. It's the language of tRump and Nazis bc vermin are killed on sight. . . .nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Jan 12
#49
Hah! You are mistaken to think I control anyone's vocabulary. And tRump doesn't own the word "vermin"
Bernardo de La Paz
Jan 13
#60
tRump does not define you or make you a failure. Period. You can hold your head high. . . . . nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Jan 12
#13
Assuming you voted Dem, you did not fail. The 25% of registered Dems who didn't vote are failures.
dutch777
Jan 12
#28
the worrisome thing is, to me (old), how my grandkids are going to live in this world we leave to them.
CTyankee
Jan 12
#39