Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:29 PM Jan 8

Here's two copies of the same photo: the original in color, and the copy in black & white.

The original:



The copy



I can't decide which one I like better! They both have beauty. Which one do you prefer, and if you feel like it, why?


20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Here's two copies of the same photo: the original in color, and the copy in black & white. (Original Post) CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 OP
Peggy I love them both BOSSHOG Jan 8 #1
Why, my dear BOSSHOG! Thank you. Very kind of you. CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #2
They are each uniquely perfect wendyb-NC Jan 8 #3
My goodness, thank you so much, my dearwendyb-NC! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #4
The one in color gets my vote. The creamy white... 3catwoman3 Jan 8 #5
Thank you so much, my dear 3catwoman3! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #8
I would love that, thank you! 3catwoman3 Jan 8 #10
Ah, you're very welcome! I will do it later tonight, but I will do it. CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #12
I like... 2naSalit Jan 8 #6
And thank you for your excellent critique, my dear 2naSalit! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #9
Both are nice... 2naSalit Jan 8 #14
Thank you for your tender concern, my dear 2naSalit . . . We are fine. CaliforniaPeggy Jan 9 #15
I am strongly biased in favor of color fargone Jan 8 #7
I appreciate your critique a lot, my dear fargone! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 8 #11
The color one. The Madcap Jan 8 #13
Thanks for your definitive answer, my dear Madcap! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 9 #16
Both are beautiful, but HAB911 Jan 9 #17
Thanks so much, my dear HAB911! CaliforniaPeggy Jan 9 #18
I vote for the BW canetoad Sunday #19
Thank you so much, my dear canetoad! CaliforniaPeggy Sunday #20

BOSSHOG

(40,549 posts)
1. Peggy I love them both
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:32 PM
Jan 8

If there were two of you I’d love both of you.

I thoroughly enjoy taking the camera out for a spin.

3catwoman3

(25,873 posts)
5. The one in color gets my vote. The creamy white...
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:39 PM
Jan 8

…of the petals, the gentle green of the leaves, and the subtle silver whatever-it-is (maybe the cellophane wrapping?) in the background provide a luscious contrast to the few red stamen in the middle of the blossom. A perfect splash of color.

I really, really like it and would happily hang a framed copy of it in my house.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
8. Thank you so much, my dear 3catwoman3!
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:47 PM
Jan 8

The color version is very lifelike, of course! I like the way the colors work as well.

If you would like a copy, I can PM you that. I would be proud to have my photo hanging in your home.

3catwoman3

(25,873 posts)
10. I would love that, thank you!
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:51 PM
Jan 8

Not quite sure where I’ll put it, but I know I’ll find a place.

Our younger son is a self-employed photographer/videographer, so I’ll get him to print it on some good quality paper. He’s much more tech savvy than I am.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
12. Ah, you're very welcome! I will do it later tonight, but I will do it.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:53 PM
Jan 8

I have things I need to be doing right now!



And how cool that your son can print a copy for you!

2naSalit

(94,181 posts)
6. I like...
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:42 PM
Jan 8

The B&W best. I like the color but the B&W is more crisp and defined, probably because it's easier to control the lighting w/o the color getting in the way. You can see the graceful lines of the petal edges in the B&W.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
9. And thank you for your excellent critique, my dear 2naSalit!
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:49 PM
Jan 8

It is crisper! I actually made no changes (other than cropping) to this version. This is just how it turned out.

2naSalit

(94,181 posts)
14. Both are nice...
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 11:23 PM
Jan 8

But the B&W is better, I think. I like to see the edges of the petals for definition, they just showed up better in this case.



You're probably getting smoked out by now, are you okay? Earlier my sister, in SD, said she thought she could see smoke approaching. There are so many fires now that probably everyone down there will get some.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
15. Thank you for your tender concern, my dear 2naSalit . . . We are fine.
Thu Jan 9, 2025, 12:33 AM
Jan 9

The nearest fires are about 17 miles away in a heavily wooded but also built-up area. That's Pacific Palisades. The other fires are to the north-east, nearer to Pasadena.

If we've gotten any smoke, it's been pretty dilute. It's such a horrible situation.

fargone

(263 posts)
7. I am strongly biased in favor of color
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:44 PM
Jan 8

The BW is merely dark in the center. The color has the splash of rust colored stamens. To be fair the color one has some messy distractions around the edges which were cropped out in the BW so the two images differ in things other than color.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
11. I appreciate your critique a lot, my dear fargone!
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 10:52 PM
Jan 8

I love color too, but . . . the B&W draws me in. Perhaps because I took the photo? Dunno.

It's true they're not identical, which also makes a difference.

The Madcap

(742 posts)
13. The color one.
Wed Jan 8, 2025, 11:09 PM
Jan 8

Normally, I would vote for a B&W photo, but there's just something about the many shades of green in the color one that captures my focus.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
16. Thanks for your definitive answer, my dear Madcap!
Thu Jan 9, 2025, 12:35 AM
Jan 9

It does have some great color combinations. I especially like the pistils in the center!



HAB911

(9,407 posts)
17. Both are beautiful, but
Thu Jan 9, 2025, 07:33 AM
Jan 9

I live by color, having done a lot of B&W over the years, I feel a missing dimension. Very nice!

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
18. Thanks so much, my dear HAB911!
Thu Jan 9, 2025, 12:14 PM
Jan 9

That certainly makes sense. I very much appreciate your input.

canetoad

(18,407 posts)
19. I vote for the BW
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 01:30 PM
Sunday

It hides any small imperfections in the flower. I like the cropping too - the blossom fills the whole frame.

CaliforniaPeggy

(152,683 posts)
20. Thank you so much, my dear canetoad!
Sun Jan 12, 2025, 04:42 PM
Sunday

I was very happy with the way the cropping turned out.

Filling the frame is one of my goals.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Photography»Here's two copies of the ...