Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

kentuck

(115,918 posts)
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:02 PM Friday

If you gave the bottom 300 million people in this country $3,000 each...?

You still would not have a trillion.

You would have $900 billion dollars.

I say that we give those 300 million Americans a check for 3,000 each and just tax one man.

Elon Musk would still have a $100 billion dollars left to play with, and would still be one of the richest men in the world.

It is so obscene.

58 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
If you gave the bottom 300 million people in this country $3,000 each...? (Original Post) kentuck Friday OP
Trump's tariffs and gas and general price rizes have applegrove Friday #1
It's mostly our tax money anyway Blue Full Moon Friday #2
This is a system that just developed through the last 1200 years bucolic_frolic Friday #3
If he had more than 2 billion in liquidity, I'd be surprised. haele Friday #4
Slightly Different Spin Here ProfessorGAC Friday #6
"..the markets would panic..." a very few people now having the financial gravitational pull of a black hole. harumph Friday #10
Like 1998. Like 2007. Like..... paleotn Friday #32
But he can take out obscene and sweetheart deal loans Aviation Pro Friday #18
Torch all the cash. Everyone's. All of it. OC375 Friday #5
You're saying exactly what I was talking about when 911 hit. slightlv Friday #20
Umm, no thanks DFW Saturday #42
Cash was a poor word choice on my part. OC375 Saturday #52
I like this particular aspect of the Space X offering. Frasier Balzov Friday #7
Are the employees allowed to cash in their windfall or is it just on paper??? nt in2herbs Friday #9
Rolling tranches over six months can be resold. Frasier Balzov Friday #14
Interesting proposition. Too bad we can't do national level grass roots ballot initiatives. dutch777 Friday #8
You can, but they are extremely cumbersome to bring to reality DFW Saturday #40
$100 billion??? PatSeg Friday #11
To have all that money, and not distribute it to ease pain and suffering Grim Chieftain Friday #12
One time in my life I worked for DoD as a contract worker slightlv Friday #21
I know what you mean DFW Saturday #41
When governments and individuals are valued in the mega dollars . . . Aussie105 Friday #13
I still think a tactic of the poor (99%) vs the rich (1%) KS Toronado Friday #15
Those that invested in this IPO are the ones who are likely to lose. Bev54 Friday #16
It would be a serious boost to the economy bc poor people would spend it on necessities ms liberty Friday #17
Death to trillionaires. N/T Coventina Friday #19
lol, I'm limping along on caretaker money for a clinic MerryBlooms Friday #22
Sorry, been a really rough week MerryBlooms Friday #24
Vent away! You deserve to. So do the rest of us. paleotn Friday #29
It's not liquid. QueerDuck Friday #23
I'm sure that Musk pays a high tax rate on that $54K annual salary that he collects at SpaceX. OGBuzz Friday #25
Their GDP is real. His is paper. A figment of imaginations he can't tap without crashing it. Big difference. paleotn Friday #28
Tesla trades 45-60 million shares daily. He can tap as much as he needs without crashing anything. There will be similar OGBuzz Friday #31
45 to 60 million in relatively small blocks. That's not the same thing. paleotn Friday #33
I'm pretty sure Elon has dozens, if not hundreds of brokers on the payroll. He doesn't have to go large on one trade. OGBuzz Friday #37
Irrelevant. The increase in daily activity will raise questions. paleotn Saturday #39
Daily trade volumes range from 45 million to 60 million. Those are some swings indeed and nobody is OGBuzz Saturday #43
Straw man much? paleotn Saturday #44
As stated above, it's not real. paleotn Friday #26
Giving the money to everyone won't solve many people's problems LogDog75 Friday #27
"Corporations are people, my friend" (M.Romney) Seinan Sensei Friday #35
Good ideas, LogDog75! calimary Saturday #53
I think we kind of saw this already JBTaurus83 Friday #30
Maybe then we could afford a Universal Healthcare program. Emile Friday #34
It's always funny when people say this... WarGamer Friday #36
Yep Manatee Saturday #45
That's insulting, to read you think 98% of Americans are idiots questionseverything Saturday #47
then you live around the smart 2%'ers WarGamer Saturday #48
Your 2% assertion is a lie, you are wrong and you obviously know nothing about poor and working class Americans questionseverything Saturday #49
lol... ok WarGamer Saturday #54
This is correct Easterncedar Saturday #57
On the contrary Easterncedar Saturday #51
This isn't guaranteed income, it's a single $3000 injection. WarGamer Saturday #55
All hypothetical here, right? Easterncedar Saturday #56
But the OP says give 300M people $3000 each... WarGamer Monday #58
And not only is Elon a trillionaire, it seems like it isn't enough for him. Initech Saturday #38
spellcheck does work dweller Saturday #46
The good side of it all is that he will die someday, and all the money in the world will not prevent it. NNadir Saturday #50

bucolic_frolic

(56,222 posts)
3. This is a system that just developed through the last 1200 years
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:12 PM
Friday

Some historians say the Crusades and the Knights Templar were organized like banks or corporations. Knights helped move goods and could obtain credits or make deposits on their routes.

The LLCs began the Age of Exploration. Dutch East India Company and similar. Invest in company assets, insulate yourself from liability, hire thugs to conquer the world by whatever means necessary. Early venture capital.

Then came insurance. Lloyd's of London. And the great banking houses from European capitals. Stock exchanges. Everyone wanted to make money, rarely a thought to economic inequality.

haele

(15,691 posts)
4. If he had more than 2 billion in liquidity, I'd be surprised.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:16 PM
Friday

That is what he'd need available just to do that "good deed" and still maintain the few actual bills he pays on current lifestyle for the rest of the year.

Most of that trillion dollars he claims for himself is leveraged in the debt and differments he took on to become a multi-billionaire.

ProfessorGAC

(77,573 posts)
6. Slightly Different Spin Here
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:28 PM
Friday

It's not just leverage.
His holdings and cult of "potential" that supports the gross overvaluation of his holdings create a situation where he can't liquidate.
For instance, he owns 20% of TSLA. Their valuation is a bit under $1.3 trillion. (Ignore, for now, that lack of justification for the market value.)
He can't sell any appreciable amount of it, because the markets would panic over him selling his own company's stock, and the price would plummet.
Same with SpaceX & his crypto holdings.
This negatively affects any liquidity because if one can't sell holdings for cash, it is, by definition, not liquid.

harumph

(3,494 posts)
10. "..the markets would panic..." a very few people now having the financial gravitational pull of a black hole.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:24 PM
Friday

We are prisoners of their whims.

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
32. Like 1998. Like 2007. Like.....
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 09:32 PM
Friday

The market is irrational short term. Longer term, not so much. I wonder what SpaceX's first "earnings" call will be like?

Aviation Pro

(15,869 posts)
18. But he can take out obscene and sweetheart deal loans
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:00 PM
Friday

Against his paper assets and they are protected against taxation.

OC375

(1,182 posts)
5. Torch all the cash. Everyone's. All of it.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:24 PM
Friday

Obviously it’s time for a reset on wealth. It isn’t working.

slightlv

(8,142 posts)
20. You're saying exactly what I was talking about when 911 hit.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:07 PM
Friday

Saw the future at that point, and it's one I didn't want to be part of. Tried talking to my coworker (a "libertarian" repub), and he couldn't at all understand what I was trying to say. I shake my head, cause they're no smarter now than they were then... maybe even dumber!

DFW

(60,686 posts)
42. Umm, no thanks
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 10:08 AM
Saturday

We live in Europe, a control-freak society.

The governments here want to know EVERYTHING that every private citizen does. The best way to do that is with a cashless society and everyone having cards. When Cyprus found itself in a budget crunch, it just electronically went into the bank account of everyone in the country and took 10% of every amount over €100,000. *poof* money gone.

I live in a country where the Nazis controlled everything 90 years ago, and just a few hundred KM to the East, so did Stalin (or, at least he tried). Even a couple of years ago, we were in a small town in Massachusetts in a small local grocery store when their electronic payment system broke down. They announced that they could only take cash until the system had been repaired. A young mother burst into tears because she was there to buy a $5 package of baby formula for her infant, and had only a card. My wife took pity on her, and fronted her the $5 in cash. She wanted to actually get our address to return the money. Sending $5 to Germany? Even if she sent a $5 bill in the mail, it would have cost her $1.25 in postage. My wife told her to forget it, and repay her by never forgetting to bring cash anywhere.

No government has any business knowing what food we buy, or where--or what shows or movies we see or when. They have no business knowing what books we buy, or what music we listen to. The socialist governments of Eastern Europe were like that in the mid 20th century, and their secret police collapsed under the very weight of the information they had collected on their own citizens. East Germans were astonished when they got to see the files the Stasi had kept on them. My wife and I use cash wherever and whenever we can. My wife's parents and relatives lived under the National Socialists. Some friends of our lived under their successors, the SED and their Stasi. National Socialists, Soviet Socialists, Unity Socialists, the label didn't matter. Their actions did. It was enough. No, thanks. Control freaks do not belong at the controls of any government. Let the people earn their cash and spend it as they see fit without some misfit in a uniform (or a computer screen) recording every cent and every date.

OC375

(1,182 posts)
52. Cash was a poor word choice on my part.
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 05:54 PM
Saturday

I meant money. I too am inherently skeptical of people and groups who are more than casually interested in me, and what I do. They usually want something that doesn't benefit me as much as them. In the end, it's usually my money, or my information, which of course is monetized.

Remove the money if you want egalitarianism, privacy and peace.

Never gonna happen, but it's a fun thought.



Frasier Balzov

(5,156 posts)
7. I like this particular aspect of the Space X offering.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:43 PM
Friday

A bunch of the employees are millionaires now.

Frasier Balzov

(5,156 posts)
14. Rolling tranches over six months can be resold.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:49 PM
Friday

Managed liquidity so the sell side of the market doesn't drive the price down.

I imagine many employees will be hanging onto their shares indefinitely.

Those long-term holdings will be marginable, so they can be collateral for borrowings which can support an upgrade to lifestyles with very favorable tax treatment.

dutch777

(5,115 posts)
8. Interesting proposition. Too bad we can't do national level grass roots ballot initiatives.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 06:48 PM
Friday

DFW

(60,686 posts)
40. You can, but they are extremely cumbersome to bring to reality
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 09:15 AM
Saturday

They are commonly referred to as "Constitutional Amendments."

They take quite a while and a lot of effort.

PatSeg

(53,889 posts)
11. $100 billion???
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:39 PM
Friday

For Elon, he wouldn't know how to survive on such a piddling sum. He'd have to start pinching pennies and cutting back on the extras.

Grim Chieftain

(2,262 posts)
12. To have all that money, and not distribute it to ease pain and suffering
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:40 PM
Friday

is the epitome of evil. When my husband and I still bought lottery tickets, we would talk about causes and charities we would donate money to, not what extravagances we could spend it on, but how we could help others. As I've said many times here, with Democrats, it's about we, with Republicans, it's about me.

slightlv

(8,142 posts)
21. One time in my life I worked for DoD as a contract worker
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:10 PM
Friday

and actually made good money... high five figures. Stashed away most of it for when the next string of rainy days hit, but I also used some of it to buy tickets to plays, etc... even ones that I didn't want to particularly see. Why? Because for the first time in my life, I could buy tickets for me, my Mom, and my Sister to go and share the experience together. That meant more to me than seeing the show... even CATS... ever could. The fact that I could make *their* lives a little happier. And then, contract was changed to GS and at one of the lowest levels, and hubby lost his contract. That "string of rainy days" hasn't let up yet... (sigh). But man, it was sure fun while it lasted!

DFW

(60,686 posts)
41. I know what you mean
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 09:37 AM
Saturday

Before I moved my legal residence over here, I stuck as much of my after-tax income away as I could. I already had a modest lifestyle, and that hadn't changed. I put part of it in a Roth IRA, at the end of the Cheney-Bush recession, so that I paid all taxes due at the bottom of the recession and the Dow at 7800, and could reap the benefits of the inevitable rebound as tax-paid. How naïve of me. Now, the Germans want half my income, even though my job pays me in the USA, where it is taxed. They also want half of my Roth IRA, even though I already paid 100% of the taxes due on it when I made the conversion while I was still a full-time US resident. I had enough put away to supplement the fact that between the IRS and the Germans, I am expected to pay 73% in income taxes, as well as my tax-free (under US law) retirement fund the second I take anything out of it (I haven't yet--at no point are you required to take anything out of a Roth IRA, since the very nature of it means the taxes on it were paid at the time of conversion).

Aussie105

(8,303 posts)
13. When governments and individuals are valued in the mega dollars . . .
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:46 PM
Friday

I always have my doubts.

Too many variables, and cashing in the money is problematic.

Who would buy Tesla for instance, at the current valuation? Nobody!

The current AU $600 in my wallet though, that is real money.

The good thing though, is that when Trump or Musk shuffle off the planet, there will be a fire sale and the real value of their hoardings will quickly become apparent.

KS Toronado

(24,083 posts)
15. I still think a tactic of the poor (99%) vs the rich (1%)
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:54 PM
Friday

should be used headed into the midterms. Or at least every D running for office needs to talk about
how income inequality is working against them.

Bev54

(13,553 posts)
16. Those that invested in this IPO are the ones who are likely to lose.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:54 PM
Friday

It is unbelievable people are willing to trust him. Their entire investment is reliant on AI that most, including those who are in the AI business, think is overblown.

ms liberty

(11,449 posts)
17. It would be a serious boost to the economy bc poor people would spend it on necessities
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 07:55 PM
Friday

The economy did well during the pandemic bc we paid people.

MerryBlooms

(12,518 posts)
22. lol, I'm limping along on caretaker money for a clinic
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:16 PM
Friday

Who got everything cut this year, because trump ss cola.
My 82 sis who makes too much, to qualify for medicaid for me to get paid, but not much.over. she still has co pay, type 2, sundowners, so, our schedule is messed up. lol
These jerks in charge, who admitted, they don't care? Come spend 1 24hrs in my shoes! The meds shots, suppository, cats, cleaning, yard, head to other client so I can still pay off credit card to move here to take care of my sister.
These millionaires, billionaires, now trillion, have never had to stay up and wipe someone's privates, insert suppository... read Every label on every can or bag she takes off the shelf, and explain why she can't have it, and the ride home. Then the next 2 days
Ugh, these ruch files can kiss my lily white hard working bruised arms, legs, spkut nails, fingers, And especially my Bunions!

MerryBlooms

(12,518 posts)
24. Sorry, been a really rough week
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:21 PM
Friday

Looking for better days
Have my sister cool with 100's coming
That's really what I cared about
Thanks for letting me vent
Sorry

OGBuzz

(812 posts)
25. I'm sure that Musk pays a high tax rate on that $54K annual salary that he collects at SpaceX.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:35 PM
Friday

Only 23 countries on earth have a higher GDP than Musk's personal fortune.

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
28. Their GDP is real. His is paper. A figment of imaginations he can't tap without crashing it. Big difference.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:46 PM
Friday

OGBuzz

(812 posts)
31. Tesla trades 45-60 million shares daily. He can tap as much as he needs without crashing anything. There will be similar
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 09:02 PM
Friday

volumes traded at SpaceX.

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
33. 45 to 60 million in relatively small blocks. That's not the same thing.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 09:34 PM
Friday

You're conflating apples with oranges. That's regular activity. Any significant moves by Elmo would be on top of that and would be noticed very, very quickly.

OGBuzz

(812 posts)
37. I'm pretty sure Elon has dozens, if not hundreds of brokers on the payroll. He doesn't have to go large on one trade.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 11:13 PM
Friday

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
39. Irrelevant. The increase in daily activity will raise questions.
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 08:54 AM
Saturday

Few things of any size are kept secret for long on Wall Street. People talk. They talk a lot.

OGBuzz

(812 posts)
43. Daily trade volumes range from 45 million to 60 million. Those are some swings indeed and nobody is
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 10:26 AM
Saturday

raising any questions. Anyhow, you win, it's all just worthless paper and Elon is barely scraping by.

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
44. Straw man much?
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 11:33 AM
Saturday

That very last part. Says a lot more than you think about things other than Elmo.

paleotn

(22,994 posts)
26. As stated above, it's not real.
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:45 PM
Friday

It's paper. Not money in his pocket. And if he tried to liquefy even a tiny portion, the market would take that as an "oh, shit!" and the stock would plummet. Thing is, not much in this frankenstein company actually makes much money other than maybe Starlink. The rest is hype. Pure, unadulterated bullshit. At least Tesla made cars people bought.

This company makes nothing but stupid claims. And after disappointing earnings cycle after disappointing earnings cycle, the stock will get savaged. May happen sooner than we think. AI data centers in orbit? That's so patently stupid and unworkable it boggles the mind almost as much as the idea of people living for any significant amount of time on Mars. It ain't happening, folks.

LogDog75

(1,436 posts)
27. Giving the money to everyone won't solve many people's problems
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 08:46 PM
Friday

Instead, the money should be used to change the way our nations economic system runs to reduce the pay equity between the rich, the middle class, and the poor.

First of all, we need to change the tax codes to prevent the wealthy from being able to influence the government on the taxes they pay. They should have no more tax breaks than the average citizen has like individual/married, deduction, SALT deductions, child credit deduction, etc...

Second, we need to increase the taxes on those making over $500,000 raising it in graduated rates where the more you earn the more you pay in taxes. IMO, the highest tax rate should be 75% for federal taxes.

Third, CEOs are limited to 15 times the average pay of their employees. Any amount the CEO and top corporate managers make above the 15 times limit will be taxed at a higher rate.

Fourth, pass a law that saws corporations are not people but are an artificial entity and therefor do not have the same or more rights than a human being. Corporations have limited free speech rights but no rights to influence the federal, state, or local governments on the enactment of laws or taxes.

Undoubtedly, there are more things but the idea is by reforming how our economy and tax polices function from favoring the wealth to the average citizen will benefit everyone at every level. The monies collected from taxing the wealthy and corporations can be used to reinforce the social safety net that has been shredded since the Reagan administration.

Seinan Sensei

(1,711 posts)
35. "Corporations are people, my friend" (M.Romney)
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 10:08 PM
Friday

Nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope!

And do-away-with Citizens United.
Yesterday, if possible.

JBTaurus83

(1,805 posts)
30. I think we kind of saw this already
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 09:01 PM
Friday

During Covid. Every business just knew Americans had some extra cash sitting around and raised their prices. I’m definitely fine with placing a very large tax on that douche bag though.

WarGamer

(18,929 posts)
36. It's always funny when people say this...
Fri Jun 12, 2026, 10:42 PM
Friday

One... $3000 wouldn't change a thing for 98% of the public... they'd buy a big screen tv a weekend in Vegas or clothing.

SOME would pay bills or tuition... very few.

And the old "Elon can give away XXX"

Elon Musk doesn't have 100B in the bank.

He probably doesn't have ONE billion in the bank.

Musk is probably the least liquid of the top billionaires... no yachts, no mega mansions and no Bugatti.

So when you say... "Musk can give away $XXX you're saying sell stock and if the amount of stock sold is large enough the stock price dips which affects the retirement accounts for regular folks... Even the CLPRS retirement fund invests in Musk led businesses...

Literally, CLPRS... the California State Retirement fund holds 5,000,000 shares of TSLA.

So who gets hurt?

questionseverything

(12,187 posts)
47. That's insulting, to read you think 98% of Americans are idiots
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 03:42 PM
Saturday

Perpetuating the welfare/caddy system

I live in a working class neighborhood and when my neighbors get their tax refunds, they do buy their kids shoes, sorry if kids having shoes w/o holes bothers you, but they also get their cars fixed so they can get to work w/o an hour bus ride first, they pay off their payday loans that they had to take or starve, and they spend their refund in a hundred other ways to survive and if a kid gets a new bike and that bothers you ( insert nasty, painful meme here)

questionseverything

(12,187 posts)
49. Your 2% assertion is a lie, you are wrong and you obviously know nothing about poor and working class Americans
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 04:10 PM
Saturday

You are as wrong about this as you were about Ukraine

Easterncedar

(6,632 posts)
51. On the contrary
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 04:40 PM
Saturday

Social experiments have proved that providing small guaranteed income is a good investment by local governments. Recipients raise themselves out of poverty by interrupting the destructive cycles of cost of living debt. The cost to government is offset by the reduced calls on its welfare system. Everyone wins.

Easterncedar

(6,632 posts)
56. All hypothetical here, right?
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 07:30 PM
Saturday

There are studies, easy to find online, by NIH and Kennedy Research with various scenarios of cash disbursal showing benefits. The idea that poor people go buy big TVs isn't ever shown as a result.

WarGamer

(18,929 posts)
58. But the OP says give 300M people $3000 each...
Mon Jun 15, 2026, 07:10 PM
Monday

Thus my claim that 98% will fritter it away.

Initech

(109,527 posts)
38. And not only is Elon a trillionaire, it seems like it isn't enough for him.
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 12:16 AM
Saturday

He wants it all. And he's destroying more governments to get it. The man is a fucking monster who deserves nothing but prison time.

NNadir

(38,786 posts)
50. The good side of it all is that he will die someday, and all the money in the world will not prevent it.
Sat Jun 13, 2026, 04:14 PM
Saturday
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If you gave the bottom 30...