General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums"What the Democrats ought to do..."
I hear this line all the time. Its good to know that people have opinions and want to help, but too often I hear this from people whove never done anything more than Monday morning quarterbacking in politics. Yesterday I attended a party sponsored coffee at one of our local residents homes. A man was there doing the same thing he did at the last such event: Mansplaining to the hard working women that dominate and hold up the local party. (Where are you men?) This man has never been to a single party meeting, nor any other event besides this coffee one other time. The women he was lecturing to, on the other hand, brought this party from a dead shell, with an absent chair and sleeping executive committee to a thriving, growing force in the community. The women he was lecturing are responsible for quadrupling the number of precinct chairs in the county, for tripling voter participation in the midterms, for hosting almost a dozen fundraisers in the last year for candidates and for the local party, and for filling the meetings with so many participants weve had to move locations TWICE. They can take credit for coordinating a dozen protests in the community as well as participating in more than a dozen voter drives and public events across the county in the last year alone. Yet this man found it appropriate to mansplain personally to more than one of the mature women volunteers that has been working to hold up this party for decades.
Not only is that kind of behavior arrogant and condescending, its detrimental to the morale and the goals these Helpful Hannahs claim they support. And it makes them look like assholes. If you truly want to help build this blue wave, show some respect and appreciation for all the hard work people have donated to support democracy. ASK what you can do to help. If a policy or practice doesnt make sense to you, ASK someone to explain its purpose.
The work that volunteers do isnt easy and its thankless enough without people whove never been in the trenches criticizing and critiquing. Further, dont assume that former practices are the only ones being implemented in the current election cycle. Big changes are happening in Texas, for one thing, and I can bet similar seismic shifts are going on across the nation. Texas has a new state chair and the DNC has a new chair. You may not like everything about these people, but you shouldnt assume they cant bring much needed change to the party. If you want to see change, roll up your sleeves, stand beside these volunteers and get to work.
If you live in Texas and you want to help, call your local party office and find out who your precinct chair is. Your precinct is the US representative district in which you liveits on your voters card. Ask your local office how to get in touch with your precinct chair. Offer your precinct chair help for block walking, post card writing, making calls, holding or helping with events to bring together voters in your precinct. Your precinct chair will have very specific tasks that need to be done and instructions for carrying them out. Become a volunteer voter registrar and attend voter registration drives. ASK what you can do to help the local party and precinct chairs. This is the only way we will build a solid blue wall of change.
I know that a lot of the criticism comes from a sense of powerlessness and frustration. But there is MUCH you can do that is far more effective and empowering for you AND your community if you will offer your help instead of merely your critique.
QueerDuck
(2,081 posts)It is common to hear unsolicited advice on how the party should operate, often from people who do not participate in day-to-day efforts. While the desire to help is understandable, "Monday morning quarterbacking" from those outside the trenches can be counterproductive and demoralizing to the volunteers doing the actual work.
The Problem with Unsolicited Criticism
At a recent local event, a man who rarely participates spent his time lecturing the women who have been the backbone of the organization. These women have:
-- Transformed the party from an inactive state to a thriving, influential force.
-- Quadrupled the number of precinct chairs.
-- Tripled midterm voter participation.
-- Hosted numerous fundraisers and coordinated regular protests and voter drives.
When people who have never been involved offer condescending critiques to these dedicated volunteers, it creates an atmosphere of arrogance. It damages morale and undermines the very goals these critics claim to support.
How to Actually Make a Difference
If you want to help build momentum, shift your focus from critiquing to contributing. Instead of offering unsolicited advice:
-- Show appreciation: Respect the hard work and time volunteers have already donated.
-- Ask questions: If a strategy is unclear, ask about its purpose rather than assuming it is wrong.
-- Be patient with change: Recognize that leadership at the state and national levels is evolving. Do not assume you know more about current strategies than those implementing them.
Get Involved
The most effective way to address feelings of powerlessness is to take direct action. If you live in Texas or elsewhere, here is how you can help:
-- Contact your local party office: Find out who your precinct chair is (this information is on your voter card).
-- Offer specific help: Ask about block walking, postcard writing, phone banking, or assisting with events.
-- Become a registrar: Get certified to register voters and show up for local drives.
The work is difficult, but it is the only way to build lasting change. If you want to see a difference, roll up your sleeves, stand with the volunteers, and get to work.
Trueblue Texan
(4,704 posts)I intended the tone I wrote it. While your edit might have been helpful to some, it did not convey the subtext I intended. Most here are accomplished readers and writers. I trust my audience received my message clearly. I am honestly trying to be polite here.
QueerDuck
(2,081 posts)And ... I was also "honestly trying to be polite" too. 🥰🍷🍷🫂 But I do sense the irritation in the tone of your reply.
Trueblue Texan
(4,704 posts)So I guess I wasn't in the mood for yet another man to tell me how or what I should say or do. Soooooo...
Scrivener7
(60,297 posts)And let him know he had made himself look somewhat foolish but could make up for it by doing what you suggest.
Trueblue Texan
(4,704 posts)He seemed receptive.
Scrivener7
(60,297 posts)rampartd
(5,427 posts)we need a think tank capable of opposing the conservatives. heritage is well funded and seem to be steering their agenda.
we need a comprehensive project , a "plan of action with milestones"
the laws we need, the precedents we need set, the judges we need to appoint can be assigned appropriate priorities and done when possible..
dnc? their job is fundraising, not policy?
SocialDemocrat61
(8,264 posts)Interesting because I've always seen DU as similar to a fan site for a football or baseball team, with fans who have never played, coached or worked in sports second guess in the professions.
Scrivener7
(60,297 posts)SocialDemocrat61
(8,264 posts)Who decides that?
Scrivener7
(60,297 posts)the posters here. So it's puzzling that you would want to be here.
SocialDemocrat61
(8,264 posts)Please dont put words in my mouth.
kentuck
(115,975 posts)Your Honor.