Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Industry of the Future Is Run By People Who Hate Each Other (New York magazine, 4/19)
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/why-all-the-ai-leaders-hate-one-another.htmlOne thing you hear about a lot from the tiny group of extraordinarily wealthy and powerful people in charge of Americas AI companies is that, as the world sits on the cusp of potentially massive economic, social, and perhaps even spiritual transformation, it is time to figure this out together. I believe we are entering a rite of passage, both turbulent and inevitable, which will test who we are as a species, wrote Anthropics Dario Amodei earlier this year, suggesting that one way to make it through will be to encourage coordination at the level of industry and society. AI will be the most beneficial technology ever created, Googles Demis Hassabis has said, but only if we apply it in the right way and build it in the right way. (Just as you can tell youre reading AI-generated text from all the bullet points, or an insistence on describing everything as not x, but y, a telltale sign that youre hearing from an AI executive is a pleading, tic-like overuse of collective pronouns.) We (the whole industry, not just OpenAI) are building a brain for the world, OpenAIs Sam Altman explained in a post about the coming gentle singularity, which is why its important that we can robustly guarantee that we get AI systems to learn and act towards what we collectively really want.
A lot of what were hearing about us is really about them, of course, and intends to signal in the context of growing AI backlash, but also varying degrees of genuine personal angst and uncertainty that they can be trusted to shepherd a technology that, if built and deployed the wrong way, they say could tear apart society, summon authoritarianism, or worse. Its an awkward message. The public, according to numerous recent polls, finds it less appealing the more they hear it. You can blame AIs image problem on a lot of things: Vague pressure to use it at work; suddenly abundant AI slop and spam; individually offputting and polarizing founders; ideological objections to how its trained and deployed; foreboding, energy-hungry data centers that communities are turning against across the country. Mostly, of course, its fear about jobs.
But theres one factor undermining the messaging from Altman, Amodei, Hassabis, and others that is both underrated and, perhaps, a blind spot for the industry: A lot of these guys absolutely and obviously despise one another.
The AI industry is defined by research, technological breakthroughs, and billions of dollars of eager capital, sure, but also by petty resentments, estrangements, and raging blood-feuds, many of which have been building for years. Been thinking a lot about whether its possible to stop humanity from developing AI, wrote Sam Altman to Elon Musk in 2015, shortly after Google had acquired DeepMind. Given that it seemed like it would happen anyway, he wrote, it seems like it would be good for someone other than Google to do it first. Musk, who had told Altman that DeepMind was causing him extreme mental stress and that, should Google win, it would be really bad news with their one mind to rule the world philosophy, was receptive after recently failing to lure Hassabis to his constellation of companies instead. Soon, they became cofounders of OpenAI. By 2018, a bitter power struggle led to Musk cutting ties with OpenAI, leading to years of court battles, some still ongoing. Now, the men tweet openly about how much contempt they have for one another. (Altman on Musk: I dont think hes, like, a happy person. I do feel for him. Musk on Altman: Scam Altman lies as easily as he breathes.) Anthropics founding was the result of a core group of researchers and employees leaving OpenAI over concerns about its approach to safety, but also about Altmans character specifically. (Amodei on Altman in 2021: The problem with OpenAI is Sam himself. In 2026, after OpenAI seized on Anthropics conflict with the Pentagon: Altman is telling straight up lies and gaslighting.) In 2023, Musk, now in possession of Twitter and a clearer public political identity, finally founded his own firm, xAI, to build a maximum truth-seeking AI that tries to understand the nature of the universe, but also because Sam Altman was making ChatGPT woke, which he said could be deadly. (Elaborating on the theme, and making sure not to miss anyone, Musk posted at Amodei earlier this year: Your AI hates Whites & Asians, especially Chinese, heterosexuals and men. This is misanthropic and evil.)
-snip-
A lot of what were hearing about us is really about them, of course, and intends to signal in the context of growing AI backlash, but also varying degrees of genuine personal angst and uncertainty that they can be trusted to shepherd a technology that, if built and deployed the wrong way, they say could tear apart society, summon authoritarianism, or worse. Its an awkward message. The public, according to numerous recent polls, finds it less appealing the more they hear it. You can blame AIs image problem on a lot of things: Vague pressure to use it at work; suddenly abundant AI slop and spam; individually offputting and polarizing founders; ideological objections to how its trained and deployed; foreboding, energy-hungry data centers that communities are turning against across the country. Mostly, of course, its fear about jobs.
But theres one factor undermining the messaging from Altman, Amodei, Hassabis, and others that is both underrated and, perhaps, a blind spot for the industry: A lot of these guys absolutely and obviously despise one another.
The AI industry is defined by research, technological breakthroughs, and billions of dollars of eager capital, sure, but also by petty resentments, estrangements, and raging blood-feuds, many of which have been building for years. Been thinking a lot about whether its possible to stop humanity from developing AI, wrote Sam Altman to Elon Musk in 2015, shortly after Google had acquired DeepMind. Given that it seemed like it would happen anyway, he wrote, it seems like it would be good for someone other than Google to do it first. Musk, who had told Altman that DeepMind was causing him extreme mental stress and that, should Google win, it would be really bad news with their one mind to rule the world philosophy, was receptive after recently failing to lure Hassabis to his constellation of companies instead. Soon, they became cofounders of OpenAI. By 2018, a bitter power struggle led to Musk cutting ties with OpenAI, leading to years of court battles, some still ongoing. Now, the men tweet openly about how much contempt they have for one another. (Altman on Musk: I dont think hes, like, a happy person. I do feel for him. Musk on Altman: Scam Altman lies as easily as he breathes.) Anthropics founding was the result of a core group of researchers and employees leaving OpenAI over concerns about its approach to safety, but also about Altmans character specifically. (Amodei on Altman in 2021: The problem with OpenAI is Sam himself. In 2026, after OpenAI seized on Anthropics conflict with the Pentagon: Altman is telling straight up lies and gaslighting.) In 2023, Musk, now in possession of Twitter and a clearer public political identity, finally founded his own firm, xAI, to build a maximum truth-seeking AI that tries to understand the nature of the universe, but also because Sam Altman was making ChatGPT woke, which he said could be deadly. (Elaborating on the theme, and making sure not to miss anyone, Musk posted at Amodei earlier this year: Your AI hates Whites & Asians, especially Chinese, heterosexuals and men. This is misanthropic and evil.)
-snip-