General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIt's not about just Iran
I have a background in petroleum derivatives and have worked extensively in the region.
I see this as a wider move against China. China is the largest threat to the US and our economy. Iran threat is nuclear and are largely not supported by their Arab neighbors due to support of regional terrorist factions. The Arab countries now are focused on development and growth away from oil. The last thing they want are rogue nations costing them money and reputation.
China has lost their top two oil suppliers in a matter of months. The nations who ignore the US sanctions on Iran oil purchase it in the global markets at a substantial discount. When we see Chinese goods flooding markets, they are typically not advantaged in a raw material basis to the US. But what they are getting in the background is Iranian and Venezuela oil at a ~15%- 20% discount and Russian oil at a 20%+ discount. This is a lot of the money when you hear China subsidizes its manufacturing so its why things are so cheap.
This is a huge profit center for China, Turkey, India. This is being dismantled. The world oil markets are being leveled. The backend oil markets will not advantage China.
Russia is now it. China will take as much as possible discounted oil. If Iran stabilizes oil prices will likely drop as the risk premium on the straits will be removed. Russia will lose further war revenue. Not to mention Russia just lost its major 3rd party supplier of drones.
The attack is on Iran. The wider picture is an attack on the infrastructure of China.
flamingdem
(40,845 posts)Never heard that one
Melon
(1,342 posts)Prices.
I typed on my tablet and have shaky fingers.
IronLionZion
(51,089 posts)flamingdem
(40,845 posts)IronLionZion
(51,089 posts)3_Limes
(431 posts)Effectively pushing China towards leadership in the technologies that will replace petroleum and simultaneously wedding ourselves to soon-to-be obsolete energy sources for the foreseeable future. Leaving our children with an America that runs on technologies purchased from China.
Smart!
Melon
(1,342 posts)Because of their lack of key raw materials. They are not basic in oil. They also have a major issue with pollution.
You cant get away from oil unfortunately for China. Their manufacturing of plastics is all downstream from Naptha. They dont have the oil and NG reserves to support.
The northern and central region of China rely on coal for energy because thats what they have.
Oil is not just energy. Its a raw material.
So the game is still on.
NNadir
(37,776 posts)Um, there is absolutely no evidence, none, that so called "renewables" have anything to do with the use of fossil fuels. The expenditure of trillions of dollars on so called "renewable energy" has had no effect, whatsoever, on the use of dangerous fossil fuels.
In fact, "renewable energy" is dependent on fossil fuels. It is widely reported that the sun is not available 24 hours a day, nor does the wind always blow.
The Chinese are making an effort to displace their coal dependence, but it is with nuclear energy, not renewables. Nuclear energy is reliable, something so called "renewables" are not.
I would certainly advise anyone buying into the "renewables will save us" Kool-Aid, to read this excellent, new book on the topic:
The Elements of Power
Subtitle:
...By Nicolas Niarchos
I'm reading it right now, although I have long understood that so called "renewable energy" is not renewable, nor has it ever been about displacing fossil fuels, on which it depends. It was always about attacking the last best chance humanity had at eliminating fossil fuels, nuclear energy.
I personally believe that Chinese support for so called "renewable energy" is to support the rather dirty lanthanide mines in Baotou.
Melon
(1,342 posts)China is coal dependent central and north. They have a pollution problem that renewable energy can help. But its not displacing oil in the near term.
NNadir
(37,776 posts)If one shuts a coal plant because the wind is blowing and/or the sun is shining, one has to burn more coal to restart the cooled plant.
If one places a pot of water on the stove, and it boils, and then one turns off the heat, and comes back two hours later, the water will need to absorb heat before it boils again.
The same thing applies to coal powered plants. Either one burns coal to keep the plant ready or one wastes coal to reheat the plant.
So called "renewable energy" is useless. It's not clean; it's not sustainable; and it is not even "renewable."
China's main source of electrical power generation is coal.
Melon
(1,342 posts)China has massive renewable investment because they have a massive pollution issue combined with high power consumption. They are a net importer.
Green energy is not a sole source as you say. You can add it to a power grid like a normal source. An example is Texas today using about 35% green energy on the ERCOT grid.
In order to have green energy used to require 3x the grid investment because of the swings in availability. The change came with Tesla. Tesla battery technology changed green energy grid planning. Industrial batteries allow plants to run solar and keep power overnight. There are now many competing technologies that China uses.
I have been in large chemical plants with acres of solar panels in the US and Mexico. They may not use batteries but run the majority of energy off of solar during the day. Example Celanese Clear lake plant. China can do the same.
China uses coal primarily. Its dirty. There solution used to be just telling every other plant to shut down when the air gets too dirty.
KT2000
(22,075 posts)Why bomb Dubai?
Melon
(1,342 posts)Irans neighbors dont like them. They de-stabilize the region. Its not the people its the government. Oman is neutral so thats who they speak with. Its why Oman arranges regional negotiations.
The mentality in the region also has a degree of saving face. They have to respond. You notice they are not shooting at the US warships in the Straights? They arent shooting at Tankers in the straights? They know theyll lose their navy in 8 hours and all of their shore batteries.
lame54
(39,476 posts)Act irrationally then lie about the results
That's all they're about
yardwork
(69,214 posts)Dan
(5,060 posts)So, if China is the ultimate threat, you have to ask the question. Where does this lead us as it relates to China? Trump wants us to go back to using coal, the Arab nations are looking at getting away from oil, and China is buying all the oil it can - but what is their future energy direction. I read somewhere that China is developing the best batteries, etc.
I just come back to the idea that Trump is playing checkers and China is playing chess.
Melon
(1,342 posts)Oil is a commodity. But the impression here and by much of the press is that its flat. Thats not the case. China buys a massive amount of oil but will effectively lose a 15-20% subsidy. This is passed all the way through their manufacturing. Its huge.
China is effectively getting boxed in. China does produce good batteries. Ive met with professors working on battery technology for BYD. But understand that Tesla has good technology and others including Korea. Battery technology is advancing. The chemicals we sold for use by BYD into their batteries are derived from petroleum or NG.
The US wont go back to coal. Its not possible. You can bring a few power plants online, but new construction plants are designed for 30 years. Its not coal. Once we moved away from coal the infrastructure was put to other uses.
pcdb
(95 posts)China was buying oil from Iran in Yuan and not the Petrodollar (USD). You can look at any foreign policy decision in the last three decades and link it back to our need to keep the USD as the world's reserve currency.
Melon
(1,342 posts)Alliance. Same point. Further weakening of China.
cachukis
(3,822 posts)and are consciously playing it?
Melon
(1,342 posts)The administration absolutely. They are systematically dismantling the current system that supported historically communist countries.
Venezuela
Iran
Cuba - is close to falling
China
Russia. -
cachukis
(3,822 posts)pass the prices on, how is it good for the world?
Iran's economy is troubled, as is Russia's and China's.
Displacing Maduro has not really replaced the regime. The Ayatollah has designated his replacements and China has a gigantic economy.
What is the trump end game?
Melon
(1,342 posts)As the board has members from all over the world.
I dont want to walk this back all the way through economics, but China taking an unfair advantage in raw materials kills global manufacture.
Europes chemical industry, which was the historic start of much of it, is in shambles. They have just started applying large duties to Chinese products to try and protect their industries. China is overbuilding massive capacity in global chemicals and basically shipping the at cost globally. Their driving is employment and driving out competition.
The result is the shutting down of domestic production followed by the inevitable large increase in prices once domestic competition is eliminated. Predatory pricing out of China is a tactic not a gesture. They are not our friends.
Germany is a manufacturing economy as an example. Google layoffs chemicals in Germany. BASF, Lanxess, Oxea, Dow
once large industrial producers close it is gone.
China is on the same global land grab for resources. In Africa and Latin America. Their loans are not to help, they are to secure ports and resources once the country inevitably defaults.
cachukis
(3,822 posts)cachukis
(3,822 posts)the administration is aware.
I suspect, as they have been coming up for a justification, members brought this into the conversation. I firmly believe the money games brought about in the Abraham Accords opened up this can of worms. BiBi has been pushing his animosity for years. MBS decided to diversify his economy during his takeover. Trump is the perfect catalyst. The Sunni gravitation to the west has unsettled the Shia. October 7 appears to be a grenade into the Accords. MBS went to trump as has BiBi setting up to pick the fruit when it was ripe. It is the grift that moved the donald.
China needs oil, yes, but the real estate crash, the gigantic idle inventories, banking crises et al have forced them to make adjustments. They manage.
Trump's people have no script to work from. Scuttlebut in the press is referring to your kind of analysis. So while that story seems to be coming out, I don't think it ever crossed trump's inner circle brain. They seem to trip over escapes.
Frasier Balzov
(5,002 posts)For the national patriotic objective of reclaiming Taiwan.
An event which surely must be imminent now.
By doing so, China will have captured the world's most important supplier of semiconductors.
The U.S. military and its contractors are very busy already, and may not be able or willing to stop it.
Melon
(1,342 posts)Theyll just be forced to buy at the same market price as everyone else.
Jbraybarten
(221 posts)Demsrule86
(71,531 posts)Melon
(1,342 posts)It is maybe to much too type with my one finger.
It is going to level the manufacturing playing field and raw materials. You can still be advantaged on labour etc.
The US is advantaged on raw materials.
Europe is not.
China is not. But they have been subsidized to be advantaged by buying sanctioned oil at a discount.
Sogo
(7,130 posts)nt
Melon
(1,342 posts)Demsrule86
(71,531 posts)A bunch of women and kids were killed already...and Netanyahu scrambled back to Israel...leaving our soldiers to clean up the mess he, Trump and Saudi Arabia created. There is no excuse...that satisfies...and I am throwing this out there...any Democrat that supports this gets a primary as soon as we can... Time to stop the billionaires who are destroying our country for profif.
Melon
(1,342 posts)Last edited Sun Mar 1, 2026, 05:56 PM - Edit history (1)
View because I am versed in it. I dont want to share too much on my background but Im not googling answers.
You can take it or leave it. Im absolutely not using this post to advocate, Im educating.
We are seeing a global shift in the world right now. That is my larger picture. At the end of the day I also see things as an American. Ive been to these areas and negotiated in China. They arent friends of ours.
I dont want any American to die. But I see panic in some area of our side on oil prices etc which Im trying to explain. If you were an expert in rubber ducks and there was a large rubber duck attack, Id appreciate your insight.
Were tired of US greed and US Imperialism.
The US does not own our planets resources.
Sick of it
period.
Everybody is a threat to the biggest bully on the planet.
None of the global elite give a shit about the poor or democracy. They want to control what belongs to all of humanity.
Enough already. China is not my problem.
wiggs
(8,760 posts)conditions based on deep knowledge, intelligence, careful planning, and wisdom.
When do MSM and analysts give up trying to ascribe deeper, well-considered, unseen policy-making skills to his 1.25 terms in office and his entire life when -- in truth -- there is only evidence of his his endless neediness to be seen as a something other than a hollow, limited, cruel half-human?
malaise
(295,024 posts)Enough of the excuses
Sogo
(7,130 posts)remember Epstein had close ties to Israel (taught Russia how to manipulate Trump), was probably an agent for Mousad, as well as an agent for Russia....
malaise
(295,024 posts)Enough already with the madness of king Donvict and his regime.
1WorldHope
(1,969 posts)You have a world view, experience and understanding that I can't touch, so I won't argue with you.
I hate to think that anything that criminal does, is helpful to the world in any way, on purpose or accidental. One thing for sure the world is changing rapidly and I am terrified.
Melon
(1,342 posts)I cant publish my experience or background that would give me credibility to rely on my opinions. But I am versed in the subject. But at the end of the day, its an opinion. Im not in the government. But what Ive said about the economic cost to China is true. Oil is a key to many things globally including funding Russias war. Putin seems to not care about the number of deaths but without money and supplies the war cant continue forever.
The people doing the analysis and a lot of the calls the government makes for expertise are not wholly Trump assets. Expertise takes decades and the industry is not big enough to find experts with every administration. If this comforts anything at all.
We will see how it plays out. There are huge unknowns regarding random radicalized followers taking action etc., but these military actions are just as clearly a warning to other countries. They are all using similar air defense systems that are effectively powerless against US warplanes and missiles. Maybe this is giving others second thoughts about pursuing their own military actions.
wnylib
(25,598 posts)Looks like the sex angle might have been a lure to bring people in, or mlre likely, a "luxury" for the elite to celebrate their status. They could indulge fantasies without consequences.
Exp
(879 posts)paleotn
(22,003 posts)Last edited Sun Mar 1, 2026, 05:35 PM - Edit history (1)
I have serious doubts.
And your comment on cost of goods from China is simplistic. Yes, cheap oil helps some, but that's only a small part of the equation.
Do you know that China accounted for more than half of ALL renewable energy installations in 2025? Over 430 gigawatts. They're up to 3.3 TERAwatts in renewable sources now. Over a third of their energy consumption and 3 times the renewable infrastructure as the US.
Edited to take out the harshness. Sorry about that. Cost of good produced is a corner of my world. The things driving Chinese costs right now are still cheap labor, though not nearly as cheap as it once was, massive government subsidies, and extraordinarily high volume. They've addressed their increasing labor costs by introducing huge amounts of automation. And not AI driving automation. Just interesting modifications of off the shelf robotics that's been around for years. "Lights out" production is a thing there now, where the only humans are maybe a couple of techs wandering around somewhere making sure the equipment doesn't catch on fire or the few tasks not yet automated. They're significantly ahead of US and European production facilities in that.
Response to paleotn (Reply #37)
Melon This message was self-deleted by its author.
Melon
(1,342 posts)I wrote it in a way for a wider audience to understand.
What does your solar comment have to do with the discussion? Solar is energy. China is not advantaged on energy cost.
I dont think you understand much of the premise which is why you perhaps think its simplistic. Oil at a discount is used to make the raw materials that drive their manufacturing. Both in the sale of chemicals and goods. This is a big component of why you see Chinese goods as cheaper and many countries applying duties and tariffs to China in particular to protect home industries.
You are dropping in solar. China is the largest importer of energy in the world.
struggle4progress
(125,919 posts)Melon
(1,342 posts)Oil is funding Russia. If prices remain stable or elevated, the war is where its at today.
Oil prices go down, Russia loses money to fuel the war and run the economy. The Russian population has supported Putin despite losses of so many men, but if the economy collapses and they are losing men
.?
Who is financing the war in Europe? China and Turkey are buying the oil at a discount. I believe India has now stopped. EU is buying the majority of Russias natural gas, followed by China. EU is buying NG from Russia. This has gone down since the US started exporting but they buy a lot from Russia.
yardwork
(69,214 posts)Easterncedar
(6,012 posts)GreatGazoo
(4,541 posts)Iran was on the list of "7 countries" that Wes Clark revealed after 9/11 twenty five years ago. Long before deglobalization started. Iran was the country in that region that the USA had the least influence over and was the biggest supporter of militias that threatened and attacked Israel for decades.
The increase in oil prices benefits Canada and Russia since their production is unaffected. It hurts China but that was not the goal.
maxrandb
(17,368 posts)I don't think China is just going to sit back and allow the US to control the global oil supply.
To me, your "theory", although plausible and possible, could be subtitled; "how World War III starts".
Forgive me for not sharing in the "rah-rah".
Ferrets are Cool
(22,741 posts)THEY HAVE NO PLAN.,