General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIt's a slippery slope (and Samsung is now on it) between AI photo editing tools and a full-on slop machine.
https://www.theverge.com/tech/883225/samsung-galaxy-unpacked-s26-2026Im talking, of course, about AI slop. Last week, Samsung put out a blog post promoting a new seamless Galaxy camera experience on its newest phones. Based on the examples in the article, that experience includes turning a picture of a puppy into cute little stickers, filling in the part of a cupcake you took a bite out of, brightening video in low light to make it more lively, and editing a picture of a cow in a field to make it look like its being abducted by aliens.
Harmless, right? You can do most of that with Samsungs AI editing tools already, and the blog post implies that youll be able to make these kinds of edits with natural language simply by asking in your own words. But heres the line that has me worried were not just in for an easier path to cute puppy stickers: Mobile cameras are moving beyond capture, it says. Lets Im so sorry to say this unpack that just a bit.
-snip-
Beyond capture could be a very weird destination: one where AI is no longer a tool in service of recording reality or even memories. It could very well be Slopsville USA, where you just point your camera at a sunset, press the shutter, and tell it how youd like to embellish the scene. Or maybe just describe the video you want it to create of your friend on his skateboard and let the camera app do the rest. After all, people like Sam Altman seem to think were headed for a future where the line between real and AI content is so blurry that we no longer care about the distinction. So whats the harm if the slop happens to come from your phone camera and not Sora? And is a camera that has moved beyond capture even a camera? Im not so sure.
I hate this.
The AI peddlers seem to assume we're all children with no concern for reality, so photos are just starting points for play.
Which fits with the AI-slop image generators, for which AI companies stole the world's art and photos to allow people with no talent and skill who never bothered to learn how to create art or take good photos to pretend they can.
And it fits with the AI music generators to allow lazy wannabes to pretend they have some talent and can create music.
Meanwhile, the AI companies have stolen all the work of real artists, photographers and musicians to keep people playing mindlessly, distracted, as AI bros pat them on their heads and tell them they're actually truly creative, playing with AI companies' toys. They just need to pay for those toys, at least with lots of time spent on platforms serving them ads, or subscribing to AI tools that will become increasingly expensive since users are being hooked, not helped.
I hope the AI users will wake up someday, and not regret too many days capturing AI slop instead of real photos with real memories. Too many days telling a chatbot to create art or music, or write a story or poem or essay, instead of developing those skills and doing that writing and creating that art and music themselves.
The companies will be happy to keep those users/customers entertained like babies with an endless assortment of crib toys. Completely dependent on their AI tools and companions, with little reality inside their AI-generated crib, and little interest in anything beyond it.
That's the capture AI companies are interested in. Reality and people who are actually using their own minds and creativity, not so much.
cachukis
(3,800 posts)in 1992. Worked on rasterization to get rid of jaggies.
Watched as the power of computing advanced at breakneck speed. Saw video become the shooting match.
Suspected the entertainment factor of video, games, video conferencing, PowerPoint presentations would evolve into its own economy.
When the Smart Phone arrived, the switch from analog to digital, was complete.
The immediacy of information from the shared resource of the internet, made memory almost obsolete. Practice to perfection is for the professionals in a field.
I am very afraid that Hal will control the human experience unless measures are taken to stop the money machine. The commitment is so ginormous there is no stopping it beyond failure.
In spite of some wanting to go back to the "purity" of the 50s, that is not going to happen.
This is going to be resolved by the younger generations who have no to little concept of the analog world. Their minds work differently.
I don't think AI has advanced as far as it will, but my son, who works for a company that relies heavily on building algorithms, sees it seeping into everything.
He worries about companies becoming Macrohard. Practicing his sweeping methodology, to stand out, if it comes to it.
He can hit a nail and change a tire, but beyond that, he needs YouTube.
We are selling our minds to a machine and from what I'm reading, not caring if the machine screws up because nobody will know.
Initech
(108,275 posts)It sucks. And for some extremely bizarre reason, it's targeted at white Christian conservatives.
Don't patronize this garbage. AI slop needs to die the horrible death it deserves.
hunter
(40,542 posts)It's bad enough that I have to own a cell phone (my wife and kids coerced me into that) and lately now a cell phone seems to be necessary for "two factor authentication" too.
I don't go shopping for a new cell phone until I lose or break my old phone. Then I spend a few days searching for the most primitive 4G LTE cell phone I can get.
When I was a feral young creature I lived out of a post office box and there were no cell phones. My parents and my siblings didn't always know where I was living and could only hope for the best. Sometimes it wasn't for the best. Thankfully I survived to tell the tales.
Now, as a parent I'm happy my own children have had cell phone since high school and I can call or text them. They've never ignored my occasional inquiries for more than a day or two. And I'd prefer they not wander out into the wilderness alone without their cell phones.
But there were so many times in my youth when I needed solitude to keep my mind straight --to be swimming in the surf naked on a deserted beach or running through a forest. A cell phone would have ruined that.
These newer cell phones (and I mean anything that's a flat Steve Jobs style slab) are the stuff of my dystopian nightmares.
Intractable
(1,846 posts)I took note of that.
I want to be more like them (but without all the violence).