Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

gab13by13

(31,609 posts)
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 10:49 PM 13 hrs ago

The Schumer/Jeffries Softening On Masks

Got me to thinking. We have had a lot of debates here regarding moderates v progressives, some people still have scars.

I don't think it's a moderate v progressive issue here. I say hey Chuck, have Chris Murphy help you negotiate. Hey Hakeem have Jason Crow help you negotiate.

Murphy and Crow aren't far left progressives, but they do have courage.

No fucking masks and make them wear identifiable uniforms with name tags. That's not asking a whole hell of a lot. FFS.

65 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Schumer/Jeffries Softening On Masks (Original Post) gab13by13 13 hrs ago OP
This isn't even a negotiation leftstreet 13 hrs ago #1
Here's the deal, gab13by13 13 hrs ago #6
i think a lot more ppl r sick of the 'moderates' than the 'radicals'. mopinko 12 hrs ago #13
You couldn't be more right FoxNewsSucks 12 hrs ago #32
I think Dante's lowest circle of hell is for moderates. ananda 11 hrs ago #36
Moderates are the people pushing Bettie 2 hrs ago #57
Overton Window ananda 2 hrs ago #60
Yep, what is currently called "the far left" Bettie 2 hrs ago #61
Would they? Cirsium 10 hrs ago #42
Said "pummeling" certainly would have been the case a year ago, now "abolish ICE" seems the sane, moderate position 0rganism 7 hrs ago #50
Exactly Cirsium 11 hrs ago #41
I'd start with dismantling DHS tishaLA 10 hrs ago #44
K&R spanone 13 hrs ago #2
We should be saying, "You guarantee there'll be no more murders, kidnappings, illegal entries, Scrivener7 13 hrs ago #3
Democrats should have Congressional Magats by the short hairs. gab13by13 12 hrs ago #12
Me too. Again. Scrivener7 12 hrs ago #15
no masks wear a badge creon 13 hrs ago #4
Some of their uniforms only say POLICE, gab13by13 13 hrs ago #8
that is wrong creon 2 hrs ago #56
Who is giving them such horrible advice? Chasstev365 13 hrs ago #5
I don't want any softening on this. Takket 13 hrs ago #7
dumb ass david axelrod is warning mopinko 12 hrs ago #9
F Axelrod. We don't need ICE like we need a police force. mzmolly 12 hrs ago #11
personally, i understood it. mopinko 12 hrs ago #20
I understood it, too. But it had to be explained as you note. mzmolly 12 hrs ago #23
The Democrats are using the same playbook AZProgressive 12 hrs ago #27
And at the same time, Steve Bannon is saying ICE mzmolly 12 hrs ago #28
It's OK for protesters to hold up signs that say Abolish ICE gab13by13 12 hrs ago #19
Good plan!! mzmolly 12 hrs ago #30
I agree with your take on this thread AZJonnie 8 hrs ago #48
Effn weak leadership vapor2 12 hrs ago #10
The article that started the hysteria that led to more Democratic bashing *literally* included Murphy. W_HAMILTON 12 hrs ago #14
I'm waving my ABOLISH SCHUMER protest sign in front of the computer, muttering personal insults at Democrats, betsuni 11 hrs ago #39
Yeah, I asked WHY The OP in That Thread Left OUT THIS PART? Cha 10 hrs ago #47
K&R red dog 1 12 hrs ago #16
Elect more moderates this year so we can have more of this! DJ Synikus Makisimus 12 hrs ago #17
I absolutely hate this EnergizedLib 12 hrs ago #18
Yeah, and I'm so sick of my vote being taken for granted. FoxNewsSucks 12 hrs ago #33
The so-called leadership is worse than useless. dalton99a 11 hrs ago #40
OUT WITH THE SECRET POLICE PARAMILITARY GARB. usonian 12 hrs ago #21
Masks are used to TERRORIZE. no masks!!! IcyPeas 12 hrs ago #22
I'm unsure I agree with the headlines on this. mzmolly 12 hrs ago #24
There is no "softening on masks". FascismIsDeath 12 hrs ago #25
I think the masks are unfortunately necessary gulliver 12 hrs ago #26
Why should ICE be permitted masks thucythucy 12 hrs ago #31
They are being targeted in an organized way gulliver 11 hrs ago #35
Law enforcement has always been a relatively risky profession. thucythucy 11 hrs ago #37
But we have "law enforcement" using cheap IT to track and attack citizens. THAT is where the law is breaking down. Scrivener7 2 hrs ago #58
WTF?????????????? FoxNewsSucks 12 hrs ago #34
No. 0rganism 7 hrs ago #51
You're actually defending ICE masks? aocommunalpunch 6 hrs ago #55
Yup. Scrivener7 2 hrs ago #59
The police do not wear masks pinkstarburst 1 hr ago #64
It's a very difficult problem gulliver 13 min ago #65
How about we also demand, before any money is approved, thucythucy 12 hrs ago #29
Real negotiations would start with disarming ICEholes Hassler 11 hrs ago #38
Also getting to dress up in their cosplay "Tactical" costumes that they bought with the money AZJonnie 8 hrs ago #49
Damn Cirsium 10 hrs ago #43
trump is wasting huge amounts of tax payer money for his own powerr and enjoyment. C Moon 10 hrs ago #45
I can't believe that people are discussing negotiating with the fascists! ! Bread and Circuses 10 hrs ago #46
Interesting that you specifically mentioned Chris Murphy EdmondDantes_ 7 hrs ago #52
Seems like he had to mitigate the gaffe by restating the fact that masks should be prohibited by law. Scrivener7 2 hrs ago #62
I'm sick of them malaise 7 hrs ago #53
Shocking I tell you! luv2fly 6 hrs ago #54
Amen. And if you can't manage any guts, fucking retire. Joinfortmill 1 hr ago #63

leftstreet

(39,455 posts)
1. This isn't even a negotiation
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 10:52 PM
13 hrs ago

To negotiate you start with ABOLISH ICE

Then the other sides say OMG no - how about we'll remove masks

Then your side says...

etc.

What a joke

gab13by13

(31,609 posts)
6. Here's the deal,
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:01 PM
13 hrs ago

Democrats will get pummeled if they say abolish ICE, there's another way.

DHS funding expires Feb. 13th, if Democrats were to just demand that the Gestapo goons must follow the law, such as having local and state police be allowed to investigate the Good/Pretti killings and any other shootings, with full access to evidence collected by the Feds, guess what, Congressional Magats will not agree to that. Then let the funding expire and blame Magats for not agreeing to reasonable rules.

Democrats have the upper hand here if they stay strong, but Schumer and Jeffries are off to an awful start.

mopinko

(73,402 posts)
13. i think a lot more ppl r sick of the 'moderates' than the 'radicals'.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:11 PM
12 hrs ago

ppl want to fight. if there’s no 1 w any fire, they’ll stay home.

FoxNewsSucks

(11,537 posts)
32. You couldn't be more right
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:58 PM
12 hrs ago

Fuck these cowardly republican-appeasing "moderates".

It's too late for that.

ananda

(34,581 posts)
36. I think Dante's lowest circle of hell is for moderates.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:10 AM
11 hrs ago

I've thought this for a long time.

ananda

(34,581 posts)
60. Overton Window
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 09:49 AM
2 hrs ago

I had to look it up, and that is exactly right.

It makes what used to be unacceptable, acceptable.

Bettie

(19,439 posts)
61. Yep, what is currently called "the far left"
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 09:53 AM
2 hrs ago

were called moderate Democrats not too long ago.

The mainstream Republicans we have now used to be the fringe, the nutjob theocrats on the far right.

0rganism

(25,517 posts)
50. Said "pummeling" certainly would have been the case a year ago, now "abolish ICE" seems the sane, moderate position
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 04:09 AM
7 hrs ago

Last poll I saw, a hefty chunk of the electorate deeply fucking hates ICE now, so abolishing ICE and CBP would not be the extreme political belly flop it once was. However, it would require significant effort to massage this idea smoothly into the news cycle of a press deeply embedded in F47's anus, which is perhaps why they took the alternate approach they did.

Your 2nd-para take is likely how events unfold, but somehow Schumer and Jeffries make the Democrats look weak even when we're getting a strategic win. Somehow it comes off as lesser, underpowered, careless, even when it's the best Dems could reasonably do. This is just bad PR. Granted, the media hill has become quite steep over the last decade, but someone other than Sen. Schumer needs to be announcing party positioning on important issues.

Cirsium

(3,616 posts)
41. Exactly
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:07 AM
11 hrs ago

You never start negotiations with the very least that you would settle for. That's what I say. But who am I? They are playing a game that is so sophisticated and so far above our meager understanding that we cannot even begin to fathom just what the hell it is that they are doing. I'm sure it will all work out great. It's been good so far, hasn't it?

tishaLA

(14,751 posts)
44. I'd start with dismantling DHS
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:17 AM
10 hrs ago

It was created in the wake of 9/11 but it's a behemoth with too much power and too little oversight. If we break it up, not funding DHS is no longer related to things like FEMA

Scrivener7

(58,837 posts)
3. We should be saying, "You guarantee there'll be no more murders, kidnappings, illegal entries,
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 10:54 PM
13 hrs ago

assaults on protestors, terrorizing of children, and then we can talk. Till then, you better not be asking us for anything."

Instead, while they're pulling that shit and making no plans to stop, we're going to get into a conversation on when masks are acceptable?

What is wrong with those people?

gab13by13

(31,609 posts)
12. Democrats should have Congressional Magats by the short hairs.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:10 PM
12 hrs ago

Make the Gestapo get court warrants before busting into private property.
Allow local and state police to investigate the Good/Pretti killings. Investigate every time a Gestapo goon fires his weapon, regular police get investigated.
Demand that local politicians, lawyers, the members of the MSM, clergy, be allowed in concentration camps.

Schumer and Jeffries, come up with a list of those demands and then get your people united to not vote for funding until those demands are met.

I feel that Democrats are going to steal defeat from the jaws of victory.

creon

(2,029 posts)
4. no masks wear a badge
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 10:54 PM
13 hrs ago

ICE does not wear a mask
wears a visible badge with serial number.
and a visible name plate.

gab13by13

(31,609 posts)
8. Some of their uniforms only say POLICE,
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:03 PM
13 hrs ago

that isn't enough, doesn't identify who they work for.

Chasstev365

(7,359 posts)
5. Who is giving them such horrible advice?
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 10:54 PM
13 hrs ago

More importantly, why can't they have the courage to hold firm and say NO NEGOTIATIONS ON THIS POINT?

mzmolly

(52,713 posts)
11. F Axelrod. We don't need ICE like we need a police force.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:09 PM
12 hrs ago

I never agreed with the "defund police" mantra. But I agree that ICE should be abolished.

mopinko

(73,402 posts)
20. personally, i understood it.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:15 PM
12 hrs ago

it was just too short. but saying ‘reform’ doesnt work, cuz that’s been tried over and over and over, and nobody buys that any more.
defund doesnt mean abolish. it means take away their spendy toys, and send other professionals to do the shit cops dont want to do anyway. i never cd come up w a pithy way to say that, tho. i’m usually pretty good at that. explaining complex things to idiots may b impossible in this enshittified age.

mzmolly

(52,713 posts)
23. I understood it, too. But it had to be explained as you note.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:20 PM
12 hrs ago

It was an asinine talking point. That said, Minneapolis has come a long way since the dark days of Bob Kroll, thankfully!

AZProgressive

(29,883 posts)
27. The Democrats are using the same playbook
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:42 PM
12 hrs ago

that they used to counter defund the police are actual accountability the leadership pushed "reform" such as body cameras which hasn't made the police less violent and a lot of footage from body cameras never see the light of day. The same playbook they used to counter outrage against police they are using for ICE.

I agree with you as far as ICE not being as important as local police departments but Democratic leadership is using the same playbook against real ICE accountability the same as they countered outrage over the local police departments.

mzmolly

(52,713 posts)
28. And at the same time, Steve Bannon is saying ICE
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:44 PM
12 hrs ago

will be used to intimidate voters. They’re saying what the game plan is. Complaining after they steal an election isn’t going to do us any good.

gab13by13

(31,609 posts)
19. It's OK for protesters to hold up signs that say Abolish ICE
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:14 PM
12 hrs ago

but Congressional Democrats have to be smart about it.

Make the demands, strong demands, and sure as shit, Congressional Magats will say no. Well then when Feb. 13th rolls around, funding for DHS expires and Magats can be blamed for it.

W_HAMILTON

(10,222 posts)
14. The article that started the hysteria that led to more Democratic bashing *literally* included Murphy.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:11 PM
12 hrs ago
But Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), who joined Jeffries and Schumer behind the lectern, said there has been no significant shift.

betsuni

(28,876 posts)
39. I'm waving my ABOLISH SCHUMER protest sign in front of the computer, muttering personal insults at Democrats,
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:04 AM
11 hrs ago

but still don't know why I'm supposed to be angry.

Cha

(317,670 posts)
47. Yeah, I asked WHY The OP in That Thread Left OUT THIS PART?
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:41 AM
10 hrs ago
"Just common sense dictates that there are sometimes safety reasons why you may need a mask,” Murphy told HuffPost. “But no, I think our position is very clear, that if you’re using a mask to obscure your identity in everyday law enforcement, that should be prohibited by law.”

https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=20996652

DJ Synikus Makisimus

(1,248 posts)
17. Elect more moderates this year so we can have more of this!
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:13 PM
12 hrs ago

Complicity and collaboration, not confrontation!


#antifademocratsforrevengeandretribution

EnergizedLib

(2,973 posts)
18. I absolutely hate this
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:13 PM
12 hrs ago

The biggest scum control the trifecta, and we have the most feeble leadership to combat them.

Once again, the Dems don’t inspire me to vote for them, MAGA inspires me to vote against them.

FoxNewsSucks

(11,537 posts)
33. Yeah, and I'm so sick of my vote being taken for granted.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:01 AM
12 hrs ago

I want to vote FOR politicians who will kick fascist ass. Not look for ways to appease them.

mzmolly

(52,713 posts)
24. I'm unsure I agree with the headlines on this.
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:23 PM
12 hrs ago
“Police officers don’t wear masks. Sheriffs don’t wear masks. State troopers don’t wear masks. There’s no justification for the manner in which ICE is conducting itself in terms of masks,” Jeffries said Tuesday in an interview with “PBS News Hour.”

“Defending ICE agents wearing masks and giving them special treatment, especially when they are so brutal and thuggy, is totally against the views of most Americans who want basic accountability,” Schumer said Tuesday on the Senate floor.


https://www.huffpost.com/entry/democrats-ice-masks-dhs-shutdown_n_69839db8e4b053ac3e17298d

FascismIsDeath

(96 posts)
25. There is no "softening on masks".
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:30 PM
12 hrs ago

As I said in another thread...

They might as well get ahead of the ridiculous reasons Republicans will use to shoot down any restrictions on masks whatsoever.

"Well, Democrats are trying to get them all killed when the next pandemic hits"

"Democrats want make sure the cartels know who's family to target whenever we have agents communicating with informants"

Just take those talking points away from them now instead of having to explain themselves later. Put an iron clad proposal on the table that refutes as many of their disingenuous arguments as possible.

The goal is for ICE/BP to be held to the same standards as regular police officers as far as identifying oneself. Lets make sure that happens.

I'll also add, that you if you read what they are proposing, it will effectively prove that they hired a bunch of untrained, white supremacist, proud boy, militia types.

gulliver

(13,801 posts)
26. I think the masks are unfortunately necessary
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:36 PM
12 hrs ago

The ICE agents are running up against more and more coordinated IT.

It's a bit scary what self-organized groups are now capable of doing. I like official government agencies that conform to the law and are paid by taxpayers. I don't know who any of these other people are, and I don't think anyone does. Even they don't know who they are. They are routinely infiltrated, as we see in the news.

If Schumer and Jeffries carve out circumstances where ICE agents wear a masks, I trust their judgment.

thucythucy

(9,058 posts)
31. Why should ICE be permitted masks
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:49 PM
12 hrs ago

when state, county and local police aren't?

Or do you think all law enforcement should be permitted to operate masked and without having to show badge numbers or other identification?

What makes ICE the exception? Aren't all members of law enforcement vulnerable to "self-organized groups?"

gulliver

(13,801 posts)
35. They are being targeted in an organized way
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:09 AM
11 hrs ago

Badge numbers and ID are absolutely necessary, imo.

We can't have arbitrary groups using cheap IT to track and potentially attack law enforcement though. It's just becoming too easy to do. If left unchecked, law enforcement can become impossible to staff or perform. I think the democracy absolutely wants and absolutely needs laws.

thucythucy

(9,058 posts)
37. Law enforcement has always been a relatively risky profession.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:29 AM
11 hrs ago

The solution is to investigate, indict, and convict those that target LE using due process and the proper legal venues as established under our constitution.

Not to grant thousands of federal law enforcement agents virtual immunity from any consequences for their illegal and in some cases physically abusive and even lethal behavior by making it impossible to determine who among them are themselves breaking the law.

Personally, as a rape survivor, I have real problems with the idea of masked, heavily armed and unidentified men pulling people, including women and children, into unmarked vans. We already have instances of people pretending to be ICE committing sexual assaults and robberies. Of course, since we don't know who are ICE and who aren't, we can't be sure that at least some of these assaults weren't being committed by actual ICE agents.

Yes, democracy needs laws. And it needs law enforcement that is answerable to the people. Not a secret police force evidently answerable to no one but themselves.

There's a reason why every tyranny in history has valued the services of a secret police.




Scrivener7

(58,837 posts)
58. But we have "law enforcement" using cheap IT to track and attack citizens. THAT is where the law is breaking down.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 09:47 AM
2 hrs ago

Not the other way around.

FoxNewsSucks

(11,537 posts)
34. WTF??????????????
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:04 AM
12 hrs ago

These are the same MAGAt assholes who refused to wear a mask to prevent the spread of a deadly disease.

But it's OK with you to wear a mask to hide their identity when they murder, assault, and brutalize us?????

Jesus H Christ, this is why we lose, and why we're doomed.


Fuck!!!

pinkstarburst

(1,894 posts)
64. The police do not wear masks
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 10:58 AM
1 hr ago

They wear their name on their uniform, their badge number, their face is fully visible and they have body cameras.

This does not eliminate all problems, but it does serve as a deterrent. Let's not be naive.

The reason ICE is acting like a bunch of berzerker thugs, killing innocent civilians and pillaging and destroying everything in their path, is because they feel absolutely free to do so with no penalty of backlash because their faces are covered and they can't be identified. If their faces are uncovered, their behavior will improve. We weren't having these issues with people interested in doxxing ICE before because ICE wasn't a gang of 7 thugs surrounding an ICU nurse and executing him in the streets, or executing a mom who'd just dropped her kid off at school.

gulliver

(13,801 posts)
65. It's a very difficult problem
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 11:54 AM
13 min ago

We don't have cases where other types of law enforcement (local, state, FBI, reservation, etc.) are being doxxed. If our elected Dem leaders see that as a problem and want to do something to curb it, including with masks, I trust them.

thucythucy

(9,058 posts)
29. How about we also demand, before any money is approved,
Wed Feb 4, 2026, 11:45 PM
12 hrs ago

that a complete list of ICE agents be provided to Democratic leadership, with the understanding that the names will be cross referenced to look for convicted felons, January 6th rioters, people with a history of domestic or other violence, members of far right groups such as the Proud Boys, etc.

I repeat: this should happen BEFORE money is approved, since we know this administration will ignore any restrictions or regulations once they have the money, just as they've ignored the law on releasing the Epstein files.

Hassler

(4,813 posts)
38. Real negotiations would start with disarming ICEholes
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 12:32 AM
11 hrs ago

A paycheck and carrying a gun is the only reason these goons are ICE-holes.

AZJonnie

(3,163 posts)
49. Also getting to dress up in their cosplay "Tactical" costumes that they bought with the money
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 03:27 AM
8 hrs ago

meant for the kid's trade school that mom saved up working two jobs.

If those don't function as work uniforms, mom is really pissed.

C Moon

(13,535 posts)
45. trump is wasting huge amounts of tax payer money for his own powerr and enjoyment.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:31 AM
10 hrs ago

I don't think our Congress can see the forest for the trees (using a tired old idiom).

Bread and Circuses

(1,751 posts)
46. I can't believe that people are discussing negotiating with the fascists! !
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 01:31 AM
10 hrs ago

NO!

Shut down the government!
DEFUND ICE.

General strike!

We’ve lost time negotiating with republicans.

They are murderers and rapists.

Wake up!

EdmondDantes_

(1,509 posts)
52. Interesting that you specifically mentioned Chris Murphy
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 04:53 AM
7 hrs ago

,After the press conference, Schumer ignored a question from HuffPost about whether Democrats had changed their position on masks. But Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), who joined Jeffries and Schumer behind the lectern, said there has been no significant shift.

“Just common sense dictates that there are sometimes safety reasons why you may need a mask,” Murphy told HuffPost. “But no, I think our position is very clear, that if you’re using a mask to obscure your identity in everyday law enforcement, that should be prohibited by law.”

https://www.msn.com/en-us/politics/government/democrats-soften-their-demand-to-ban-masks-for-ice/ar-AA1VG28T

Seems like he doesn't disagree with Schumer and Jeffries.

Scrivener7

(58,837 posts)
62. Seems like he had to mitigate the gaffe by restating the fact that masks should be prohibited by law.
Thu Feb 5, 2026, 09:59 AM
2 hrs ago

They said it, he had to walk it back.

Why did they say it in the first place? What was the point of that?

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Schumer/Jeffries Soft...