General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region Forums3000 Tennessee library books pulled: topics of slavery, the Holocaust, menstruation, ancient history, unclothed animals
Library books on slavery, Holocaust pulled in Rutherford CountyBooks featuring topics of slavery, the Holocaust, menstruation, ancient history, unclothed animals were flagged as potential violations of state and federal legal standards.
Books were flagged by librarians for possible violations such as:
unclothed anthropomorphic animals, violence
Adam and Eve nude in the Garden of Eden; Violence
underpants shown during cartwheel
An image capturing an affectionate gesture where a girl gives a boy a kiss on the cheek on the school bus during Valentine's Day.
Fictional male rabbits get married
Civil War Hero, Mary, dresses in pants, history of undergarments present and modeled by chickens
Kissing
Words "ass" appears for donkey and "cock" for rooster
2 male neighbors speaking to one another, one has a rainbow and his produce bag****
LGBTQIA+ rights
implied breastfeeding
nude mummified body
classroom discussion of book bans and censorship
discussion of teen getting period
woke
Popular titles flagged and pulled include Aesops Fables, two Magic Treehouse books by Mary Pope Osborne, multiple Harry Potter books by J.K Rowling, and a Charlie Brown book by Charles Schultz.
https://archive.ph/4Dmxf
Key Points
A letter from Secretary of State Tre Hargett prompting public libraries across the state to submit a review of their collections has led to the removal of nearly 3,000 books in one county.
The letter asked public libraries to complete a review of their entire juvenile collections within 60 days and provide a report to Hargett's office to avoid the risk of losing funding.
The letter sent libraries across the state scrambling over the holiday season, even as state officials deny it was ever an order.
Books on slavery, racism and the Holocaust are among the nearly 3,000 pulled from public library shelves across Rutherford County following a letter from State Secretary Tre Hargett prompting a review of juvenile collections across nearly all state public libraries.
Four Anne Frank biographies, more than 30 books focused on the Bible, five books on womens history and suffrage and numerous books on ancient civilizations were among those removed for review.
dweller
(27,952 posts)Snoopy has no pants on?
and what is a produce bag**** ?
(most every sentence in those books have a period at the end of sentences )
✌🏻
Celerity
(53,924 posts)
riversedge
(79,882 posts)babylonsister
(172,630 posts)this extent. That's disheartening.
Easterncedar
(5,701 posts)Adam and Eve? Biblical violence?
babylonsister
(172,630 posts)me produce a big eyeroll, but that's a lot of books.
TheRickles
(3,211 posts)Joinfortmill
(20,341 posts)Red Mountain
(2,274 posts)Prosecuting pedophiles.
OGBuzz
(57 posts)Does this not qualify as anti semitism?
mysteryowl
(8,495 posts)What the hell are men afraid of? Those foolish religious right... $&@#*!
Just stop it!
milestogo
(22,763 posts)Back in the day this was not uncommon. Ignorance is not bliss.
bdamomma
(69,259 posts)call them for what they are Weak and Damaged.
BlueWaveNeverEnd
(13,247 posts)sinkingfeeling
(57,426 posts)B.See
(7,922 posts)Collimator
(2,098 posts)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rabbits'_Wedding
A black bunny rabbit and a white bunny rabbit wear flower crowns and get married. Very Subversive stuff.]
70sEraVet
(5,318 posts)I had never heard of that book, nor the silly controversy.
I enjoyed the comment the author made, after the book was attacked by The White Citizens Council of Montgomery Alabama; "I was completely unaware that animals with white furs, such as white polar bears and white dogs and white rabbits, were considered blood relations of white human beings,"
(Same link)
Collimator
(2,098 posts)I know because I read it many years ago in a school library that was part of a state institution for the developmentally disabled.
I think that the writer/illustrator just made one bunny black and the other white to evoke associations with a groom in a black tux and a bride in a white wedding gown.
All the other bunnies in the story are typical wild brown bunnies.
It really is one of the sweetest, most innocent stories that I've ever encountered. The two bunnies just play and hop around together and decide that they want to spend the rest of their lives playing and hopping around together. It's sort of the equivalent of two little children playing house and having a make believe wedding.
I feel genuinely sorry for anybody who got worked up about it.
milestogo
(22,763 posts)hatrack
(64,432 posts)Also, I checked. This isn't some remote rural county in the Great Smokies. This is almost immediately south of Nashville (the country seat is Murfreesboro).
OldBaldy1701E
(10,527 posts)Especially if you know Murfreesboro.
(Go ask those that live there about why they refuse to pay anything for the upkeep of Davidson county (Nashville), where they all work and spend most of their time, while moving to Williamson country and turning it into a wealth enclave that favors the rich and won't tax them appropriately. Go on... ask them.)
travelingthrulife
(4,699 posts)OldBaldy1701E
(10,527 posts)But, knowing what I know about that area, I would not be surprised if they did.
flvegan
(65,889 posts)Did they ban the Bible?
Unclothed animals and underpants. These are the things they're concerned with. Imagine this was your life.
Ping Tung
(4,172 posts)
evolves
(5,757 posts)Leading the way in stupid for the past 25 years 🤦🏻♀️
Picaro
(2,348 posts)Absurd.
70sEraVet
(5,318 posts)We made a request. We asked, we said please," (State Secretary Tre) Hargett said in a video posted to social media. "Theres been no order, theres been no directive.
(Same link as above)
No, no order -- just a good old-fashioned threat!
travelingthrulife
(4,699 posts)WmChris
(657 posts)Around the bonfires with confederate flags and swastikas. When will the madness end?
Mysterian
(6,226 posts)Get rid of the evil books and go to church and play with rattlesnakes.
Rob H.
(5,797 posts)After I graduated, the student LQBTQ+ group (known first as GALA, for Gay and Lesbian Awareness, then B-GALA for Bisexual, Gay and Lesbian Awareness, and now Stonewall Tigers) was working to get sexual orientation added to the university's nondiscrimination statement, and Hargett was a very vocal opponent and fought against it.
At an anti-LGBTQ+ protest at the University in the early to mid-1990s, Hargett carried a sign saying: Blacks cant help being black, Women cant help being women. Gays=/=Minority. I don't know whether he realized that the sign made him look racist and sexist in addition to being an outspoken homophobe. He also passed out religious tracts saying gay people are going to hell at a panel discussion about religion and sexuality organized by the student LQBTQ+ group (GALA or possibly B-GALA then).
In the last 30+ years, he's learned nothing and hasn't changed.
bluestarone
(21,519 posts)Religion used wrong again. Nothing worse than these religious FANATICS!! That's a FACT!
PittBlue
(4,731 posts)I was a librarian for 20 years in a school district in SW PA. In those 20 years, I had two book challenges and my administration backed me in both cases. Tre Haggert is obviously a Nazi with mommy issues.
pansypoo53219
(22,943 posts)a whole different country.
Initech
(107,810 posts)Holy shit, they are dragging us so backwards that they'll overturn Brown V Board.