Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 10:56 AM Dec 11

Is AI Making us Stupider? A short take on why that might be the wrong question. (Neil Turkewitz in Critical AI)

Critical AI - https://criticalai.org/ - is an interduscipinary journal based at Rutgers. Neil Turkewitz is an arts advocate.

https://criticalai.org/2025/08/04/guest-forum-neil-turkewitzs-is-ai-making-us-stupider-a-short-take-on-why-that-might-be-the-wrong-question/?amp=1

-snip-

In light of a number of reports about how AI use can make us “dumber,” including a recent study by MIT, I thought it might be useful to set out a few brief thoughts.

While I may have some ideas about the question of whether using AI may make us stupider, I would start with a somewhat different observation — using AI is itself stupid (and to be clear, I am using “AI” as shorthand for text/image producing generative AI models, not all forms of machine learning). It’s stupid because it valorizes the destination while eliding the journey. It’s stupid because current AI models are rooted in massive exploitation of our fellow human beings — from the cultural workers whose expression is misappropriated to train AI models, to all of us whose personal information is repurposed to create bespoke/unshared realities and to sell us goods and services, to the underpaid “moderation workers” who toil in intolerable conditions, forced to spend their days sifting through the worst detritus of human expression in a vain attempt to sanitize a commercial product.

And that’s before we even get to the issues of environmental destruction through huge consumption of energy and water involved in creating “efficiencies” of output that manage to drown truth, beauty and poetry in irrelevance, both by design and inadvertently. In short — AI, at least in its present incarnation, is a deeply toxic tree, the fruit of which is poison to our minds and dulls our senses, replacing originality with derivative output based on predictability. It is, almost by definition, a stupidity-producing machine.

-snip-


Ran across this doing some searching after seeing Neil's tweet this morning about Time magazine, which I'll post in a reply below.
21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Is AI Making us Stupider? A short take on why that might be the wrong question. (Neil Turkewitz in Critical AI) (Original Post) highplainsdem Dec 11 OP
Neil on Time's Person of the Year: highplainsdem Dec 11 #1
Not for me. I love being able to use natural-language search queries to find what I need on Google... QueerDuck Dec 11 #2
When you use AI search, you're helping AI companies destroy the websites they've stolen the highplainsdem Dec 11 #3
The genie is out of the bottle. I'll continue to use AI search engines... thank you very much. QueerDuck Dec 11 #5
No, the genie isn't out of the bottle. You're making a choice to use AI search engines, not being highplainsdem Dec 11 #7
I think it's mostly good. With any advancement there will always be people who are unhappy about it... QueerDuck Dec 11 #9
You're choosing to use AI tools completely based on the theft of intellectual property. That theft highplainsdem Dec 11 #10
It's a brand new world. Not everyone will be happy. QueerDuck Dec 11 #11
No one who's ethical should be happy with generative AI. highplainsdem Dec 11 #12
I have more important things to wring my hands over and to judge others over. AI is not going away... QueerDuck Dec 11 #13
Yes, you've made your priorities very clear. highplainsdem Dec 11 #14
Good to know. QueerDuck Dec 11 #15
Agree.... anciano Dec 11 #18
There is so much wrong with the AI race. MontanaMama Dec 11 #4
Gil Duran has done a lot of writing on just how dangerous the robber-baron tech lords are. Their highplainsdem Dec 11 #8
Marking this to read later. progressoid Dec 11 #6
The dumbing down didn't start with AI, let's be real here. Jedi Guy Dec 11 #16
They've done specific studies on genAI tools, though, showing that using them dumbs users down. highplainsdem Dec 11 #17
AI is how we achieve Idiocracy... hunter Dec 11 #19
AI doesn't make people stupid. milestogo Dec 11 #20
It's making somebody stupider. Iggo Dec 11 #21

QueerDuck

(1,009 posts)
2. Not for me. I love being able to use natural-language search queries to find what I need on Google...
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 11:02 AM
Dec 11

and the ability to add follow-up queries (in context of the original) without having to start each query from scratch is a blessing. The links and sources are much more relevant and valuable to me whether it has to do with a specific type of computer, or its operating system... or as ordinary as DIY home repair and maintenance.

It's made me smarter and more competent... it has allowed me to LEARN more rather than being stuck with trying repeatedly construct perfect queries that produce limited and poor quality results. In that regard, I think it's great!

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
3. When you use AI search, you're helping AI companies destroy the websites they've stolen the
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 11:44 AM
Dec 11

intellectual property from, because the goal of AI search is to stop the traffic there. Sometimes they provide links, but not always, and the links provided might not be the ones most relevant to the information the AI provides. Perplexity AI, for instance - which is being sued now and should be sued out of existence, as all genAI companies should - would regularly offer near-exact copies of articles from major publications, then a list of links that buried the link to the true source under links to several blogs, etc., that made some reference to the article the content was stolen from, but didn't make the actual source and extent of the theft obvious.

The AI companies' goal is to keep people in AI search, off the source websites, and to place ads in the AI search summary. It's predatory and exploitative.

And the AI answers are often wrong.

QueerDuck

(1,009 posts)
5. The genie is out of the bottle. I'll continue to use AI search engines... thank you very much.
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 11:55 AM
Dec 11

I also find great links to a lot of how-to and step-by-step videos on youtube.

And the AI answers are often wrong.
And a lot of info on youtube is wrong... let the buyer beware and use due-diligence. In my case I've found the information to be dead-on target and very useful.

Duck.ai is also a very clean and useful interface with easy to read links and results.

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
7. No, the genie isn't out of the bottle. You're making a choice to use AI search engines, not being
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 12:27 PM
Dec 11

forced to do so, and it's a choice that encourages AI companies' theft of intellectual property and destruction of the internet.

YouTube does have a lot of info that's wrong, but there's much, much more of it now thanks to AI slop videos. I've seen what AI has done to the internet described as both pollution of our information ecosystem and - more succinctly - enshittification. Both descriptions fit.

QueerDuck

(1,009 posts)
9. I think it's mostly good. With any advancement there will always be people who are unhappy about it...
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 01:08 PM
Dec 11

for example, I truly despise LED christmas light strings. They look awful! I much prefer the warm glow of incandescent C7 and C9 bulbs. But I realize that it would be futile to start a one-man crusade against LED xmas lights. Another genie that's out of the bottle. So I enjoy my own vintage lights at home, and I don't try to lecture or judge or berate my neighbors who enjoy their mini LED's, net lights, and strings of icicle "chalet" lights. They're free to do their thing and I'm free to do mine... and the world keeps on spinning. The sky isn't falling. Life goes on.

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
10. You're choosing to use AI tools completely based on the theft of intellectual property. That theft
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 01:24 PM
Dec 11

is one of the main reasons people are unhappy with genAI.

the world keeps on spinning. The sky isn't falling. Life goes on.


The world's intellectual property has been stolen by AI companies, livelihoods have been destroyed, kids are cheating their way through school with AI, all types of fraud are being perpetrated with AI, surveillance has been greatly increased, chatbot users have been pushed into breakdowns and suicide, and power and wealth have increasingly been seized by tech oligarchs who are not fans of democracy but get along just fine with Trump.

And you think that's comparable to your disagreeing with your neighbors about Christmas lights?

Wow...

QueerDuck

(1,009 posts)
13. I have more important things to wring my hands over and to judge others over. AI is not going away...
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 01:44 PM
Dec 11

better get used to it.

anciano

(2,193 posts)
18. Agree....
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 05:39 PM
Dec 11

I have found AI to be a very useful tool for saving time and enhancing creativity. And contrary to the idea that it dumbs people down, AI doesn't diminish our intelligence, just as calculators don't lessen our understanding of mathematics.

MontanaMama

(24,610 posts)
4. There is so much wrong with the AI race.
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 11:53 AM
Dec 11

One of the biggest red flags is our government capitulating to the billionaire AI companies giving them whatever they want while not having even a cursory understanding of what AI will mean for everyday people. They’re basically giving 6 people (corporations) the power to make decisions for the future of 8 billion people. Not to mention the degradation of the environment which is no small thing. AI will tear our social fabric apart and it will be replaced by nothing good.

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
8. Gil Duran has done a lot of writing on just how dangerous the robber-baron tech lords are. Their
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 12:35 PM
Dec 11

alignment with Trump and RW authoritarian governments and movements elsewhere show how little concern they have for humanity and democracy.

Even when it looked likely that Harris would beat Trump, it was obvious that the AI companies would continue to be a problem if not an outright threat. With Trump in power, it's more obvious than ever just how dangerous those companies and the billionaires behind them are.

Jedi Guy

(3,414 posts)
16. The dumbing down didn't start with AI, let's be real here.
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 02:04 PM
Dec 11

It's been ongoing and accelerating for quite some time now. The Internet has revolutionized the world in ways that people can't really grasp unless they remember the Before Times, back in the days when dinosaurs roamed the earth and you had to look at a physical phone book to find numbers.

For those of us who do predate the Internet, watching its growth and evolution has been both fascinating and repulsive. In a time when the sum total of human knowledge is available in a device 99% of us are carrying around in our pockets, how is it possible that people seem dumber and even less informed than ever before? The phones got smart and the people got dumb.

I think we can lay a fair bit of the blame on social media, personally. At first things like Facebook seemed so neat and innocent. You could keep up with your dear old great auntie Gertrude and chat with her any old time you wanted. Social media promised an era of connection and togetherness and delivered something much less benign.

Instead we learned that these free platforms were harvesting our data and selling it to the highest bidder, reducing us to a collection of data points for marketers to comb through. Turns out we were the product all along for these "free" platforms.

Then there's the increasingly obvious detrimental mental health effects of social media. When I was a kid we were safe from the bullies once we got home. Now the bullying continues apace no matter where the target is and kids can indulge their most vicious impulses anonymously, tormenting their targets with no fear of accountability.

Social media enables and promotes narcissistic behavior. Why on earth does anyone think their followers give a damn about the burger they just ordered? Why, for that matter, does some random yutz even have thousands of followers? We've watched idiotic man-children and vapid, airheaded "influencers" build media empires with no actual recognizable skills. But they sure get rewarded with millions of dollars, don't they? Then we wonder why kids want to grow up to be influencers when previous generations wanted to be lawyers and firefighters and astronauts.

Sadly the social media genie is out of the bottle just like the AI genie is. I think we can only hope that AI isn't as corrosive to society as social media turned out to be. Regardless, it's just one more manifestation of the Internet and we're stuck with it now, like it or not.

And now I'm gonna step outside and yell at a passing cloud.

highplainsdem

(59,951 posts)
17. They've done specific studies on genAI tools, though, showing that using them dumbs users down.
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 02:21 PM
Dec 11

As for the harm done by the internet, especially to kids - there are schools that separate children from smartphones, with good results. Adults can also limit screen time.

Harmful tech isn't inevitable.

It helps the purveyors and advocates of harmful tech if you say it is.

hunter

(40,367 posts)
19. AI is how we achieve Idiocracy...
Thu Dec 11, 2025, 11:26 PM
Dec 11

... not the fecundity of the not-so-bright.

Brawndo's got what plants crave. It's got electrolytes!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiocracy

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Is AI Making us Stupider?...