Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sheshe2

(96,633 posts)
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 10:15 PM Aug 2025

There is no other side to the story

There is no other side to the story

Bob (@psychobob4q2.bsky.social) 2025-08-20T01:51:42.474Z


Teach The Truth

And the legacies of slavery — lynchings, Jim Crow, disenfranchisement — were woven tightly into the American tapestry of my youth. They still echo with us. Loudly and persistently. No matter how much some would want us to ignore the clamor of justice.

As much as we wish American history were different, tragedy is part of our reality. We do a grave disservice to future generations if we sanitize the truth. People can behave horribly. Societies that profess noble values can countenance violent bigotry. We can either look back from whence we have come with clarity, or we can try to muddy the roots of the present and weaken ourselves in the process.

As much as we wish American history were different, tragedy is part of our reality. We do a grave disservice to future generations if we sanitize the truth. People can behave horribly. Societies that profess noble values can countenance violent bigotry. We can either look back from whence we have come with clarity, or we can try to muddy the roots of the present and weaken ourselves in the process.

snip


One passage that has gotten a lot of attention is for middle schoolers. It states they should learn that “slaves developed skills which, in some instances, could be applied for their personal benefit.” The danger of this narrative is striking. A system that brutalized, raped, and killed human beings while stealing their freedom and denying their humanity is rotten to its core. That enslaved people were able to find resilience and build lives in some form is a testament to their courage and spirit. There is no “other side” to the story of slavery.

It is true that these new standards, as horrific as they are, would have been a great improvement over what I learned in my segregated middle school. We have come a long way. But that was because of the bravery of civil rights leaders and activists who fought, sometimes with their lives, for a full realization of American values.Any receding from progress — as this surely is — represents a threat to our democracy. We have been strengthened as a nation, all of us, by a national movement to right the wrongs of our past.



https://steady.substack.com/p/teach-the-truth
36 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
There is no other side to the story (Original Post) sheshe2 Aug 2025 OP
DURec leftstreet Aug 2025 #1
Thank you. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #2
The horrific Truth electric_blue68 Aug 2025 #3
The truth that trump wants to bury. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #4
Yup. We'll have to remember pieces of it. ... electric_blue68 Aug 2025 #6
It is our history. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #9
I blubbered the first time I read it... electric_blue68 Aug 2025 #13
This message was self-deleted by its author sheshe2 Aug 2025 #5
Kick SheltieLover Aug 2025 #7
No one re-writes History and doesn't pay a huge price. Lies are ALWAYS Lies... BurnDoubt Aug 2025 #8
Kick BadgerMom Aug 2025 #10
Hearing the Truth shouldn't make your children feel badly... BurnDoubt Aug 2025 #11
We should feel bad and be uncomfortable when we do wrong. Irish_Dem Aug 2025 #27
YEP!!! BurnDoubt Aug 2025 #34
White people are not supposed to feel any discomfort Irish_Dem Aug 2025 #35
Anybody that is stupid enough to Cha Aug 2025 #12
They run as fast as they can from the truth, Cha. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #15
This is a bloody living Nightmare.. Cha Aug 2025 #17
Yes. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #18
Hoa Aloha, she Cha Aug 2025 #19
K&R and Amen! ReRe Aug 2025 #14
You are right, ReRe. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #16
Absolutely correct. Old Crank Aug 2025 #20
so dangerous et tu Aug 2025 #21
K&R MustLoveBeagles Aug 2025 #22
K&R...nt Wounded Bear Aug 2025 #23
That's it in a nutshell. nt mcar Aug 2025 #24
Limiting the conversation to slavery or 2% ownership diminishes the devastation of sweeping residual systemic racism. live love laugh Aug 2025 #25
The people who owned slaves were monsters Keepthesoulalive Aug 2025 #30
This. yardwork Aug 2025 #26
Slavery by another name by Douglas Blackmon. sheshe2 Aug 2025 #29
That too. It didn't end in 1865. yardwork Aug 2025 #32
We are being taken over by confederate nazis. Irish_Dem Aug 2025 #28
They left out kidnapping all their children, and/or putting applegrove Aug 2025 #31
Slavery was "Founders' Intent," DJ Synikus Makisimus Aug 2025 #33
Anyone who believes otherwise (profanity warning)... Pacifist Patriot Aug 2025 #36

electric_blue68

(26,445 posts)
6. Yup. We'll have to remember pieces of it. ...
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:08 PM
Aug 2025

The paragraph didn't mention family separation.
But as soon as I typed this I had to Google the story I partially remembered about a potato sack.
This was embroidered on the sack-

My great grandmother Rose
mother of Ashley gave her this sack when
she was sold at age 9 in South Carolina
it held a tattered dress 3 handfulls of
pecans
a braid of Roses hair.
Told her
It be filled with my Love always
She never saw her again
Ashley is my grandmother
Ruth Middleton
1921

Told in just ten lines, Ruth’s embroidered story offers a brief, powerful glimpse into the brutality of child separation under chattel slavery. Her story also prompts strong emotion: When the pouch, now known simply as “Ashley’s sack,” went on view at Middleton Place, a plantation-turned-museum in South Carolina, in 2011, so many onlookers were brought to tears that curators placed a box of tissues nearby, according to a statement.


It's now displayed at The African American Museum

If you Google "Ashley's Sack" you'll get this article (Smithsonian) with a whole lot more about how this item arrived into the present day.

And finally after the sack left the DC museum...
the artifact will eventually go on display at the International African American Museum in Charleston, which is slated to open in early 2022.

sheshe2

(96,633 posts)
9. It is our history.
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:36 PM
Aug 2025

It is not pretty, yet there should never be a need to bury it unless you want to repeat it in some form or another.

Ashley's Sack, it's heartbreaking to those who still have a heart that beats in their chest.

electric_blue68

(26,445 posts)
13. I blubbered the first time I read it...
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:47 PM
Aug 2025

these simple things yet...
An extra dress when who knows what she'd have when she arrived at her new slaveholders slave quarters. Pecans- physical sustainence on her journey. Emotional, spiritual sustainence with the lock of her mother's hair.

(I have my mom's ashes in a velveteen container from the cremation place But I might have lost the lock of her hair I took from her. sigh. Well, maybe I still have it; 2 moves later.)

Response to electric_blue68 (Reply #3)

BurnDoubt

(1,579 posts)
8. No one re-writes History and doesn't pay a huge price. Lies are ALWAYS Lies...
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:30 PM
Aug 2025

and no amount of Lies can ever change that, no matter how many times they are repeated.
Weak-minded people will still believe them, but they are still Lies.
No amount of "Believing" will change that. They are still Lies.
God won't change that, even if you have an official MAGA Trump Bible. They are still Lies.
Lies are always Lies.

BadgerMom

(3,393 posts)
10. Kick
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:36 PM
Aug 2025

I know he’s more manageable when praised but, good god almighty, I hope no one caves to this horror and goes along with the idea that any part of slavery was or is okay. The thought is immoral.

BurnDoubt

(1,579 posts)
11. Hearing the Truth shouldn't make your children feel badly...
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:44 PM
Aug 2025

unless they've been taught to hate, and intend to treat people as the Slaves were treated.
Then, yeah, they should feel badly.
We (they) got way out of the lane when this was the topic-of-the-day for the shit-stick shit-stirrers. Make it about "ME!" My FEELINGS!!!
Now, we're WAY off in the high weeds, being "led" by imbeciles.
History CAN BE a Teachable Moment if you're able to listen... and ... think.

Irish_Dem

(80,423 posts)
27. We should feel bad and be uncomfortable when we do wrong.
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 05:38 PM
Aug 2025

This is how we get a moral core.

So yes we should feel bad about our slave history.

BurnDoubt

(1,579 posts)
34. YEP!!!
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 07:29 PM
Aug 2025

We should be getting better at this Morality thing as we go along, having teachable moments everywhere we look.
"Woke" has been deemed weakness, but what is "strong" about being rude and cruel? So much easier to go with one's baser instincts and be an asshole.
Punching down is a really great way to demonstrate one's Manly Masculinity, and imposing one's will on others is a God-given Right if you're big and primitive enough to cow and intimidate people.
Worse still... They're teaching their kids to be like them.
In my seventy-four orbits around the Sun, I grew up in the Sacramento Valley with a a person raised in the Ozarks. White Supremacy was a way of life in my town, casually, where two-thirds of the names in the phone book were some version of Germanic and the three Black families "knew their place, and the myriad Hispanics were nearly invisible. Much progress has been made, and a generation-or-two might make us all Americans and able to share the good things living in Peace could bring.

Irish_Dem

(80,423 posts)
35. White people are not supposed to feel any discomfort
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 07:35 PM
Aug 2025

About the bad things they so.

Parents do not want their children to ever feel uncomfortable.

So we are becoming a nation of sociopaths.

The last thing the GOP wants is prosperity and peace. Happy content healthy educated people are harder to manipulate.

sheshe2

(96,633 posts)
18. Yes.
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 12:03 AM
Aug 2025

A nightmare that I wish we could all wake up from.

A new day rising would be a balm to our souls.

Thank you, my friend.

ReRe

(12,182 posts)
14. K&R and Amen!
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:48 PM
Aug 2025

How can we find our way forward if we don't know where we've been? We must right the wrongs of the past to make a sweeter life for everyone going forward.

sheshe2

(96,633 posts)
16. You are right, ReRe.
Tue Aug 19, 2025, 11:54 PM
Aug 2025

They can run but the facts are there for everyone to see no matter how hard he wants them hidden.

Keepthesoulalive

(2,184 posts)
30. The people who owned slaves were monsters
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 06:04 PM
Aug 2025

The people who championed it and profited from it were also complicit. Many white and white adjacent people don’t have a problem with racism just as those who stood on the sidelines didn’t have a problem with slavery.

yardwork

(69,096 posts)
26. This.
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 05:24 PM
Aug 2025

Period. I've read original documents written by slaveholders themselves. The truth is far worse than most people know.

sheshe2

(96,633 posts)
29. Slavery by another name by Douglas Blackmon.
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 05:57 PM
Aug 2025

That was also a very difficult read. And it can happen again.
Slavery by Another Name: The Re-Enslavement of Black Americans from the Civil War to World War II


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_by_Another_Name

DJ Synikus Makisimus

(1,261 posts)
33. Slavery was "Founders' Intent,"
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 06:39 PM
Aug 2025

so I think with the Federalist Society in control of the U.S. Judiciary, most with bipartisan support in their confirmation votes, we can predict what's coming. Yes?

Pacifist Patriot

(25,208 posts)
36. Anyone who believes otherwise (profanity warning)...
Wed Aug 20, 2025, 08:37 PM
Aug 2025

Can go fuck themselves with a very large cactus up the anus and play Twister while swallowing ground glass.

"Owning" another human being is evil. No other side.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»There is no other side to...